Approval
No formal approval to use applications for payment is required from HMRC. This is because this VAT planning simply uses the “Time of Supply” (tax point) legislation.
Technical
No output tax is due until a tax point is crystallised. Broadly speaking, for the supply of services, a tax point is created at the earlier of; invoice date, receipt of payment, or completion of the work. Consequently, in order to be of benefit, the services in question have to be a “continuous supply of services”. This is defined as “services are supplied for any period for a consideration the whole or part of which is determined or payable periodically or from time to time”. Therefore, if an application for payment is issued rather than an invoice, output tax is only due when payment is received. This means if the debt becomes bad, no VAT is payable on it so long as the service is continuous. An application for payment is only of benefit if there is ongoing work (continuous supply of services) since, as above, there is a tax point created when the job is complete, regardless of the invoicing or payment position. Another relevant issue is; that under the existing VAT legislation, there is no requirement to issue a proper VAT invoice to an unregistered client/customer (unless specifically requested to do so by the client).
Implementation
Sending applications for payment (rather than invoices) may be done on a job by job basis or for all services from a selected date – although, the benefit will only be obtained for those jobs which are continuous. The VAT accounting system is required to recognise and report receipts of fees rather than applications for payment or invoices raised (although if invoices are issued on the day payment is received the tax point will be the same date). Additionally, the system needs to be able to identify completion tax points since these cannot be deferred by the use of application for payment.
Documentation
A request for payment must clearly state; “This is not a VAT invoice” and it may also be helpful if it appears distinct from “usual” invoices. It should state that it is an application/request for payment. It is also helpful if it does not show the supplier’s VAT number.
Cons
If the recipient of the services is VAT registered, it may complicate their accounting and will delay the date on which input tax may be recovered. This should not affect individuals or non-VAT registered clients. As considered above, it will also affect the accounting for the supplier and may add complexity.
Summary
This is relatively simple, yet effective VAT planning. It cannot be challenged technically by HMRC, although the actual operation will be examined at an inspection.
Please contact me if this matter is of interest.