Latest from the courts
In the recent First Tier Tribunal (FTT) case of Aitmatov Academy an otherwise unremarkable case illustrates the care required when making input tax claims.
The quantum of the claim was low and the technical issues not particularly complex, however, it underlined some basic rules for making a VAT claim.
Background
A doctor organised a cultural event at the House of Lords for which no charge was made to attendees. The event organiser as shown on the event form was the doctor. Aitmatov Academy was shown as an organisation associated with the event. It was agreed that the attendees were not potential customers of Aitmatov Academy and that the overall purpose of the event was cultural and not advertising.
Issues
HMRC disallowed the claim. The issues were:
- HMRC contended that the expenses were not incurred by the taxpayer but by the doctor personally (the doctor was not VAT registered)
- that if the VAT was incurred by the Academy, it was not directly attributed to a taxable supply
- that if the VAT was directly attributed to a taxable supply, it was business entertaining, on which input tax is blocked
Decision
The FTT found that the Academy incurred the cost and consequently must have concluded that the Academy was the recipient of the supply, not the doctor.
However, the judge decided that the awards ceremony was not directly or indirectly linked to taxable supplies made or intended to be made by the Academy, and therefore that the referable input tax should not be allowed. Consequently, the court did not need to consider whether the event qualified as business entertainment.
On a separate point, the appellant contended that, as a similar claim had been paid by HMRC previously, she could not see the difference that caused input VAT in this case to be disallowed. The Tribunal explained that its role is to apply the law in this specific instance and as such it cannot look at what happened in an early case which is not the subject of an appeal.
Commentary
A helpful reminder of some of the tests that need to be passed in order for an input tax claim to be valid. I have written about some common issues with claims and provided a checklist. Broadly, in addition to the tests in this case, a business needs to consider:
- whether there was actually a supply
- is the documentation correct?
- time limits
- the VAT liability of the supply
- the place of supply
- partial exemption
- non-business activity – particularly charity and NFP bodies
- if the claim is specifically blocked (eg; cars, and certain schemes)
I have also looked at which input tax is specifically barred.
Finally, “entertainment” is a topic all of its own. I have considered what is claimable here in article which includes a useful flowchart.
As always, the message is; if a business is to avoid penalties and interest, if there is any doubt over the validity of a claim, seek advice!