Category Archives: Compliance

VAT – No more compensation for delayed refunds?

By Marcus Ward 7 September 2018

HMRC has announced its intention to do away with the 5% repayment supplement payable when it repays VAT late; it is not good news and I am quite cross.

Background

What is the repayment supplement?

Repayment supplement is a form of compensation paid in certain circumstances when HMRC does not authorise payment of a legitimate VAT claim within 30 days of receipt of the VAT Return.

If a business submits a repayment return and HMRC does not make the repayment within 30 days, it is required to add interest at 5% to the amount of the claim. A repayment claim arises when input tax is greater than output tax for a period. This may be due to many factors, such as; sales being VAT free, a large VAT bearing purchase or an adjustment to previous declarations. The 30 day period is paused for “the raising and answering of any reasonable inquiry relating to the requisite return or claim” by HMRC.

Additionally, HMRC may make an extra ex-gratia payment to make good any serious disadvantage suffered if a repayment is delayed to an exceptional extent, and the repayment supplement is less than the interest which might otherwise have been earned.

The proposal

In a consultation on draft legislation for Finance Bill 2018-19 the government has announced that it intends to replace the 5% supplement with payment of simple interest. This currently stands at 0.5% pa and therefore a substantially lower payment would be due to a taxpayer.

Technical

The relevant legislation covering the repayment supplement is contained in The VAT Act 1994 Section 79

Commentary

The entire point of the supplement is to focus HMRC’s mind on making the payment at the appropriate time, just as the default surcharge does for submitting a VAT return and paying VAT for a business. This is fair. To withdraw the repayment supplement does away with any incentive for HMRC to make repayments on time and this must represent an imbalance. To effectively withhold money from a business to which it is properly entitled is plain wrong. It can often significantly impact on cashflow and cause serious problems for a business.

It is quite often a fight to obtain a repayment supplement and in my personal experience HMRC do as much as possible to resist making these payments. It is no surprise that they are trying to wriggle out of their responsibility.

Let us hope that representations to HMRC against this plan are successful.

Right, I’m going to cool off…

VAT – deadline for EU refunds

By Marcus Ward 31 August 2018

A reminder

The refund scheme

If a UK VAT registered business incurs VAT in other EU Member States it is not possible to recover this on a usual UK VAT return. However, it is possible to make such a claim via a specific mechanism. This scheme is outlined in detail here and what may be claimed is considered in detail here

Any applicant must not be registered or registrable in the Member State from which they are claiming a refund, nor must they have a permanent business establishment in that EU country. There are a number of other rules to be considered as well, so it pays to ensure that the claim is valid before time and effort is expended in compiling a claim.

Deadline

For VAT incurred overseas in the 2017 calendar year must be claimed by 30 September 2018

This is less than a month away and UK business must allow time to register for the refund portal as an activation code is sent via hard copy in the post. That’s HMRC moving with the time folks. No sending by text or anything similarly helpful. There is no leeway to extend this deadline.

Please contact us if you have any queries or would like assistance on making a claim.

VAT – Place of supply of professional services flowchart

By Marcus Ward 23 August 2018

A question I am often asked by my legal and accountant clients is “Do we charge VAT on our invoices?” The main issue with this general question is the place of supply (POS). Consequently, I have produced a simple flowchart which covers most situations and applies to all providers of professional services. Of course, this being VAT, there are always unusual or one-off queries, but this chart, with the notes should address the most common issues.

Place of supply Of Services Flowchart

POS services flowchart

Notes to flowchart

As always, nothing in VAT is as simple as it seems. So I hope the following notes are of assistance.

Place of belonging

If the services are supplied to an individual and received by him otherwise than for the purpose of any business carried on by him, he is treated as belonging in whatever country he has his “usual place of residence”.

If the services are in respect of an individual’s business interests, then more complex rules on the place of belonging may apply. The issue is usually where more than one “establishment” exists. In these cases, the rule is the place of belonging is the “establishment” at which, or for the purposes of which, the services are most directly used or to be used.

A guide to belonging here

Property rental in the UK

Property rental is treated as a business for VAT purposes. We must decide whether a rented property here creates a business establishment in the UK for the landlord. If a person has an establishment overseas and owns a property in the UK which it leases to tenants; the property does not in itself create a business establishment. However, if the entity has UK offices and staff or appoints a UK agency to carry on its business by managing the property, this creates a business establishment (place of belonging) in the UK. VAT Act 1994 s. 9 (5) (a). In these cases, the professional services would likely be UK to UK and be standard-rated.

Difference between business and non-business:

Services provided to an individual are likely to be non-business unless the services are linked to that individual’s business activities, eg; as a sole proprietor. Therefore, an individual’s tax return is, in most cases, likely to be in the recipient’s non-business capacity (although it may be prudent to identify why a UK tax return is required for a non-UK resident individual, ie; what UK activities have taken place and do these activities amount to a business or create a business establishment?)

This is an area that often gives rise to uncertainties and differences in interpretation (particularly when deciding which establishment has most directly used the services). It may be helpful to reproduce a specific example provided by HMRC:

Example

“A UK accountant supplies accountancy services to a UK incorporated company which has its business establishment abroad. However, the services are received in connection with the company’s UK tax obligations and therefore the UK fixed establishment, created by the registered office, receives the supply.”

As always, please contact us should you have any queries.

Is tax boring?…On reflection

By Marcus Ward 23 August 2018

I am often asked as a VAT person whether I find tax boring. I do often find it frustrating, some of the mechanics arcane and dealing with HMRC something of a challenge (putting it politely). However, I have been advising on the tax for getting on for 30 years, so it must have its attractions…

I think the best way to put it is by quoting K Maurer:

Tax is not boring. Tax is politics. Tax is geography. Tax is social issues. Tax is financial literacy. Tax is financial empowerment. Tax is problem solving. Tax is helping others create a stronger sense of independence. Tax is anything but boring!

I would also add that tax is challenging as a practitioner, it is also; evaluating information, arriving at creative solutions, hand-holding, standing up for rights, explaining, challenging views and assumptions and…keeping on top of a rapidly changing legislative/legislation and commercial landscapes.

It can also be very silly.

Changes to the import of goods

By Marcus Ward 10 August 2018

If a business imports goods from countries outside the EU, there are changes being made by HMRC which it needs to beware of. If a business currently uses the UK Trade Tariff to make Customs declarations it will be affected by these changes.

The changes are set out here for imports. We understand that the changes for exports will be made available later in the year.

If a business’ agent or courier completes its declarations on its behalf, it may be prudent for a business to contact them discuss the impact of the changes.

Background

An overview of the changes may be found here

And a general guide to importing here

Why is the Tariff changing?

HMRC is phasing in the new Customs declaration Service (CDS) here from August to replace the current Customs Handling of Import and Export Freight (CHIEF) system. As well as being a modern, digital declaration service, CDS will accommodate new legislative requirements under the Union Customs Code UCC here In order to comply with the UCC, a business will need to provide extra information for its declarations which can be found in the tariff.

When will a business be required to use the new Tariff?

The majority of importers will start using CDS after November 2‌018, once their software provider or in-house software team has developed a CDS compatible software package. Some importers will start making declarations on CDS before this, but there is no action for a business to take unless it has been contacted by HMRC to be part of this group.

Brexit

As is very common with Brexit, it is unknown how the UK leaving the EU will affect this position. With a No-Deal Brexit seeming likely, the above rules are likely to apply to goods brought into the UK from other EU Member States after next March.

Please contact us should you have any queries.

VAT – Zipvit Court of Appeal decision

By Marcus Ward 18 July 2018

Latest from the courts

The Zipvit Court of Appeal (CA) case here

Background

A full background of this long running case may be found here

In summary: It was previously decided that certain supplies made by Royal Mail (RM) to its customers were taxable. This was on the basis of the TNT CJEU case. RM had treated them as exempt. HMRC was out of time to collect output tax, but claims made by recipients of RM’s services made retrospective claims. These claims were predicated on the basis that the amount paid to RM included VAT at the appropriate rate (it was embedded in the charge) and that UK VAT legislation stipulates that the “taxable amount” for any supply, is the amount paid by the customer including any VAT included in the price. HMRC maintained that the absence of a VAT invoice showing that VAT was charged to Zipvit by RM, and giving details of the rate of tax and the amount charged, was fatal to Zipvit’s claim to recover input tax.

The decisions in the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) and the Upper Tribunal (UT) went against Zipvit so the appeal went to the CA.

Decision

The CA upheld the decisions in the previous courts. The appellant failed to demonstrate that the relevant VAT had been “due or paid” on the supplies received from RM. It further appeared that evidence which was not present at earlier hearings showed that the amounts paid were exclusive of VAT which meant that VAT was not embedded in the consideration paid.

Importance

In the words of the judge Lord Justice Henderson the appeal raised some important questions of principle in the law of VAT. They arise when supplies of goods or services, which were wrongly assumed by the parties to the relevant transactions and by HMR to be exempt from VAT at the time of supply, are later discovered to have been subject to the standard rate of tax when they were made, following a decision to that effect by the Court of Justice of the European Union. Where the recipient of those goods or services was itself a registered trader which made taxable supplies on which it accounted for output tax, the basic question is whether, once the true position has become known, the recipient is in principle entitled to recover as an input tax credit the tax element of the consideration which it paid for the original supplies. If so, does it make any difference if the supplier has failed to pay the tax which should have been paid on the original supplies, and if the recipient is in consequence unable to produce a tax invoice from the supplier showing the amount of the input tax which it seeks to recover?

So a fundamental tenet of VAT was considered, as well as the matter of this being the lead case behind which many others were stood. I understand that the quantum of claims submitted is circa £1 billion in total so there was a lot riding on this decision.

Commentary

In my view, this is an important case for the above technical reasons and the whole decision bears reading in order to understand some of the intricacies of a business claiming input tax.

VAT – Making Tax Digital (MTD) Update

By Marcus Ward 17 July 2018

Time moves on and HMRC has published further information on MTD. I outlined the basics of MTD here

The recent publication lists software suppliers which HMRC say have both:

tested their products in HMRC’s test environment
already demonstrated a prototype of their software to HMRC

HMRC will update this list as testing progresses. We advise to check with your existing software supplier to see if they will be supplying suitable software for the pilot, or contact one listed below in the HMRC publication:

Background

HMRC state that more than 130 software suppliers have told them that they are interested in providing software for MTD for VAT. Over 35 of these have said they will have software ready during the first phase of the pilot in which HMRC is testing the service with small numbers of invited businesses and agents. The pilot will be opened up to allow more businesses and agents to join later this year.

Good luck everyone!

VAT Reliefs for Charities. A brief guide.

By Marcus Ward 16 July 2018

Charities and Not For Profit entities – a list of VAT reliefs

Unfortunately, there is no “general” rule that charities are relieved of the burden of VAT.

In fact, charities have to contend with VAT in much the same way as any business. However, because of the nature of a charity’s activities, VAT is not usually “neutral” and often becomes an additional cost. VAT for charities often creates complex and time consuming technical issues which a “normal” business does not have to consider.

There are only a relatively limited number of zero rated reliefs specifically for charities and not for profit bodies, so it is important that these are taken advantage of. These are broadly:

- Advertising services received by charities
- Purchase of qualifying goods for medical research, treatment or diagnosis
- New buildings constructed for residential or non-business charitable activities
- Self-contained annexes constructed for non-business charitable activities
- Building work to provide disabled access in certain circumstances
- Building work to provide washrooms and lavatories for disabled persons
- Supplies of certain equipment designed to provide relief for disabled or chronically sick persons

There are also special exemptions available for charities:

- Income from fundraising events
- Admissions to certain cultural events and premises
- Relief from “Options to Tax” on the lease and acquisition of buildings put to non-business use
- Membership subscriptions to certain public interest bodies and philanthropic associations
- Sports facilities provided by non-profit making bodies

Although treating certain income as exempt from VAT may seem attractive to a charity, it nearly always creates an additional cost as a result of the amount of input tax which may be claimed being restricted. Partial exemption is a complex area of the tax, as are calculations on business/non-business activities which fundamentally affect a charity’s VAT position.

The reduced VAT rate (5%) is also available for charities in certain circumstances:

- Gas and electricity in premises used for residential or non-business use by a charity;
- Renovation work on dwellings that have been unoccupied for over two years;
- Conversion work on dwellings to create new dwellings or change the number of dwellings in a building;
- Installation of mobility aids for persons aged over 60.

I strongly advise that any charity seeks assistance on dealing with VAT to ensure that no more tax than necessary is paid and that penalties are avoided. Charities have an important role in the world, and it is unfair that VAT should represent such a burden and cost to them.

Small businesses/start ups: Should I register for VAT voluntarily?

By Marcus Ward 6 July 2018

Why?

OK, so why would a business choose to VAT register when it need not? Let’s say its turnover is under the VAT registration limit of £85,000, isn’t it just best to avoid the VATman if at all possible?

Planning

This is not an article which considers whether a business MUST register, but rather it looks at whether it is a good idea to register on a voluntary basis if it is not compulsory. The first time a business would probably consider VAT planning.

Decision

As a general rule of thumb; if you sell to the public (B2C) then probably not. If you sell to other VAT registered businesses (B2B) then it is more likely to be beneficial.

If you sell B2B to customers overseas it is almost certain that VAT registration would be a good thing, as it would if you supply zero rated goods or services in the UK. This is because there is no output tax on sales, but full input tax recovery on costs; VAT nirvana! A distinction must be made between zero rated supplies and exempt supplies. If only exempt supplies are made, a business cannot register for VAT regardless of level of income.

Compliance

Apart from the economic considerations, we have found that small businesses are sometimes put off VAT registration by the added compliance costs and the potential penalties being in the VAT club can bring. Weighed against this, there is a certain kudos or prestige for a business and it does convey a degree of seriousness of a business undertaking. It may also make life simpler (and reduce costs) if a business buys goods or services from other EC Member States. We also come across situations where a customer will only deal with suppliers who are VAT registered.

The main issue

The key to registration is that, once registered, a business may recover the VAT it incurs on its expenditure (called input tax). So let us look at some simple examples of existing businesses for comparison:

Examples

Example 1

A business sells office furniture to other VAT registered business (B2B).

It buys stock for 10,000 plus VAT of 2,000

It incurs VAT on overheads (rent, IT, telephones, light and heat etc) of 2,000 plus 400 VAT

It makes sales of 20,000.

If not registered, its profit is 20,000 less 12,000 less 2400 = 5600

If VAT registered, the customer can recover any VAT charged, so VAT is not a disincentive to him.

Sales 20,000 plus 4000 VAT (paid to HMRC)

Input tax claimed = 2400 (offset against payment to HMRC)

Result: the VAT is neutral and not a cost, so profit is 20,000 less 12,000 = 8000, a saving of 2400 as compared to the business not being registered. The 2400 clearly equals the input tax recovered on expenditure.

Example 2

A “one-man band consultant” provides advice B2B and uses his home as his office. All of his clients are able to recover any VAT charged.

He has very little overheads that bear VAT as most of his expenditure is VAT free (staff, train fares, use of home) so his input tax amounts to 100.

He must weigh up the cost (time/admin etc) of VAT registration against reclaiming the 100 of input tax. In this case it would probably not be worthwhile VAT registering – although the Flat Rate Scheme may be attractive, please see article here

Example 3

A retailer sells adult clothes to the public from a shop. She pays VAT on the rent and on the purchase of stock as well as the usual overheads. The total amount she pays is 20,000 with VAT of 4000.

Her sales total 50,000.

If not VAT registered her profit is 50,000 less 24,000 = 26,000

If VAT registered she will treat the value of sales as VAT inclusive, so of the 50,000 income 8333 represents VAT she must pay to HMRC. She is able to offset her input tax of 4000.

This means that her profit if VAT registered is 50,000 less the VAT of 8333 = 41,667 less the net costs of 20,000 = 21,667.

Result: a loss of 4333 in profit.

As may be seen, if a business sells to the public it is nearly always disadvantageous to be voluntarily VAT registered. It may be possible to increase her prices by circa 20%, but for a lot of retailers, this is unrealistic.

Intending traders

If a business has not started trading, but is incurring input tax on costs, it is possible to VAT register even though it has not made any taxable supplies. This is known by HMRC as an intending trader registration. A business will need to provide evidence of the intention to trade and this is sometimes a stumbling block, especially in the area of land and property. Choosing to register before trading may avoid losing input tax due to the time limits (very generally a business can go back six months for services and four years for goods on hand to recover the VAT). Also cashflow will be improved if input tax is recovered as soon as possible.

Action

Careful consideration should be given to the VAT status of a small or start-up business. This may be particularly relevant to start-ups as they typically incur more costs as the business begins and the recovery of the VAT on these costs may be important. In most cases it is also possible to recover VAT incurred before the date of VAT registration.

This is a basic guide and there are many various situations that require further consideration of the benefits of voluntary VAT registration. We would, of course, be pleased to help.

VAT – Top 10 Tips for small businesses and start ups

By Marcus Ward 5 July 2018

VAT Basics

Small business and start ups have a lot of things to think about – VAT being just one. However, failure to consider VAT can lead to difficulties and penalties. So here are some pointers for new and/or growing bushiness:

Plan ahead and know when to register for VAT
Make contact with your advisers
Monitor your turnover so that you know when you are approaching the VAT registration threshold
Keep your records up-to-date and check accounting documents
Speak to us if things go wrong or there’s something you don’t understand
Deal with VAT enquiries or HMRC’s requests for information promptly
Manage the VAT within your business cashflow
Don’t worry if Customs make contact with you
Right tax – right time
If you are not happy with Customs’ behaviour or have received an unhelpful or incorrect ruling; challenge it.

The overall message is; talk to a professional at an early stage. Timing is very important for VAT and you usually only have one chance to get it right.

Finally, regarding the first point – it may benefit a business to VAT register before it is required to (a so-called voluntary registration). I shall look at that in more depth in my next article.