Tag Archives: vat-planning

New approach to VAT inspections by HMRC

By Marcus Ward 16 May 2016

A VAT quickie.

We understand that HMRC are about to introduce new plans to change the way some VAT inspections are carried out.

The intention is that when a business is selected to an inspection, rather than arranging and visiting the business in the traditional way, initial contact will be made with the responsible person. At this point a short telephone questionnaire will take place. If this option is taken then it is possible that HMRC will reconsider the need for a full inspection. This appears to be along the lines of some pre-credibility processes. It is a pilot exercise and will be entirely voluntary for the taxpayer.

If this approach enables HMRC to focus on evasion and high risk business while reducing the burden for the majority of businesses who always try to be accurate with VAT declarations it is to be welcomed. We shall see how the pilot goes and whether this is rolled out to more businesses. HMRC expects that this will be a benefit for both them and taxpayers and it is to be hoped that this is the case.

We have no knowledge currently how “brief” the questionnaire will be and how much information and preparation will be required. However, it is likely that they will focus on industry specific questions rather than on processes and controls.

If contacted by HMRC our usual advice is to contact us to ensure everything is as it should be. This may avoid penalties and ensure any enquires are concluded smoothly.

VAT – Liability of works carried out under Permitted Development Rights

By Marcus Ward 10 May 2016

HMRC has clarified its views on the zero and reduced rating of conversion construction work carried out under Permitted Development Rights (PDRs).

Who is affected?

Builders and developers who convert non-residential buildings into dwellings for which individual statutory planning consent is not required because the development is covered by PDRs. Additionally, it applies to any person carrying out a similar conversion who will be making a claim for a refund of VAT under the DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme.

What are PDRs?

PDRs are a national grant of planning permission for particular types of development. They are intended to streamline the planning process by removing the need for a full planning application, therefore reducing the amount of information required.

What has changed?

To zero-rate the sale of all newly converted dwellings (from non-residential buildings) or to make a valid claim under the DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme, the converted building must meet the requirements of a building “designed as a dwelling”. One of these conditions is that the developer, builder or DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme claimant must be able to demonstrate that statutory planning consent has been granted for a dwelling and that its construction has been carried out in accordance with that consent. In addition, part of the conditions for some supplies of construction services to be eligible for the reduced rate of VAT of 5% for the conversion of a non-residential building into a dwelling requires individual statutory planning consent.

HMRC have announced that following the introduction of PDRs, individual statutory planning consent will no longer be required for some developments making the meeting of this condition difficult.

HMRC Brief 9 (2016) sets out that when certain conditions are met, zero rating and/or reduced rating where applicable is additionally available when converting non-residential buildings to dwellings when work is carried out under a PDR. This is in contrast to work undertaken via planning consent.

Relevant parties will still be required to provide evidence that the work has been undertaken legally and that it qualifies as a permitted development.

The full guidance is here

VAT – Disbursements Q&As

By Marcus Ward 6 May 2016

Disbursements

A very common query regarding VAT is “I pass on charges incurred on behalf of my client/customer – do I add VAT?” In other words, does the payment qualify as a disbursement?

Does it matter if the original supply has VAT on it?

Yes. Whether a payment is a disbursement is only a practical issue if the charge involved is initially VAT free since, if it were VATable, there would be no benefit to the final customer in passing the charge on “in the same state”. The points below assume that the charge in question is VAT free, eg; statutory fees (land registry, stamp duty, search fees, MOTs etc) insurance, financial products etc although benefits may also be obtained if the original supply is reduced rated.

So only if a supply is a disbursement can I pass it on in the “same state; ie; VAT free?

Yes

So when can I pass on a payment VAT free?

A disbursement is passed on without any alteration (eg; not marked up or changed in any way) and the supply must be to the final customer by the original provider. If the supply is VAT free then the recovery of the costs is also VAT free. The passing on of the payment from the final customer to the supplier is done as agent. Therefore, in these circumstances, a supplier may be acting as principal for part of a supply, and agent for another part. The disbursement should not appear on the “agent’s” VAT return.

When do I have to add VAT onto a supply which is originally VAT free?

When the onward supply is not a disbursement.

A distinction must be drawn between a necessary cost component of a supplier making a supply and a disbursement. An example is zero-rated travel. A supplier may incur a train fare in providing his service, but that is a cost component for him and not a disbursement, so VAT would be added to any onward charge. It is clear that the supplier is not actually supplying train travel to his customer, but is consuming the cost in providing his overall VATable service.

What are the rules for treating a payment as a disbursement?

The following criteria must be met by a supplier to establish whether it qualifies as a disbursement:

you acted as the agent of your client when you paid the third party
your client actually received and used the goods or services provided by the third party
your client was responsible for paying the third party
your client authorised you to make the payment on their behalf
your client knew that the goods or services you paid for would be provided by a third party
your outlay will be separately itemised when you invoice your client
you recover only the exact amount which you paid to the third party, and
the goods or services, which you paid for, are clearly additional to the supplies which you make to your client on your own account.

What if I get it wrong?

If you add VAT to a properly VAT free disbursement HMRC will treat the amount shown on the invoice as VAT. However, it will not permit the recipient of the supply to recover input tax (as it is not VAT) thus creating an actual VAT cost. if you treat a supply as a VAT free disbursement when it actually forms part of your taxable supply, HMRC will issue and assessment and potentially penalties and interest. Unfortunately, I have seen this course of action taken a number of times and the amounts of VAT involved were significant.

Please contact us if you have any queries on this matter. Sometimes the matter is less than straightforward and getting it wrong can be very expensive for a business. If you have been charged VAT on what you believe to be a VAT free disbursement, it may also be worth challenging your supplier.

A guide with helpful diagrams is available here

VAT – Latest from the courts; use and enjoyment provisions

By Marcus Ward 25 April 2016

Telefonica Europe Plc and Telefonica UK Limited

The VAT Use and Enjoyment provisions set out an additional layer of rules which establish the place of supply of certain services. They apply to; telecommunications and broadcasting services; electronically supplied services (for business customers); hired goods; and hired means of transport. Broadly, effective use and enjoyment takes place where a recipient actually consumes the services, regardless of any contractual arrangements, payment, or beneficial interest. The intention of this provision is to correct instances of distortion which remain as a result of considering only where the provider and the customer belong. HMRC give the example of supplies such as telecommunications services which are actually consumed outside the EC, to be subject to UK VAT. Of course, the converse is that it would be distortive for there to be no EC VAT on such services where they are consumed in the UK.

In the Upper Tribunal case of Telefonica Europe Plc and Telefonica UK Limited the dispute involved the way in which the appellant calculated the value of its mobile telephone services which were used and enjoyed outside the EC (and thus UK VAT free). Over a number of years Telefonica had an agreement with HMRC whereby the amount of outside the EC supplies was calculated by reference to revenue, ie; comparing call, text and data income relating to non-EC supplies to total income.

HMRC subsequently formed the view that this method of calculation was distortive because higher charges were made to non-EC users than EC consumers. HMRC proposed a “usage methodology” which used call times, texts sent and volume of data used. As may be expected, this resulted in a lower percentage of supplies that were outside the scope of UK VAT thus increasing HMRC’s VAT take.

The appellant contended that the usage methodology was contrary to EC and UK VAT legislation. Not surprisingly, the UTT rejected this argument, deciding that Telefonica had not established that HMRC’s proposal was unlawful.

So then the outcome would be expected to be that the usage methodology should be used, but no. It was decided that the most accurate method would be one based on the time a customer has access to the network outside the EC; which differs from both the usage and revenue methods.

This type of dispute is quite common and also appears regularly in partial exemption situations. There are nearly always alternative ways to view apportionment calculations and it pays to obtain professional advice; not only to ensure that a fair result is achieved, but as assistance with negotiations (which may avoid having to go to Tribunal).

VAT Worldwide update – Gulf Cooperation Council Countries

By Marcus Ward 7 April 2016

VAT introduction in the Gulf Cooperation Council countries.

The following countries have indicated that they intend to introduce a VAT system for the first time from 1 January 2018:

Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates.

This is a likely result of costly military campaigns and a drop in global oil prices. Although it has been agreed that, to limit smuggling and competitiveness, the countries aim to introduce the tax at the same time it is likely that some countries may defer implementation to a later date. It is thought that healthcare, education, social services and a limited list of food items will be excluded and that introductory rate will be 5%.

Tip: Businesses trading with customers and clients in these countries may need to review their tax obligations, budgets, contracts and other arrangements before the introduction of VAT.

VAT Self-billing. What is it? The pros and cons

By Marcus Ward 24 March 2016

Self-billing is an arrangement between a supplier and a customer. Both customer and supplier must be VAT registered. Rather than the supplier issuing a tax invoice in the normal way, the recipient of the supply raises a self-billing document. The customer prepares the supplier’s invoice and forwards a copy to the supplier with the payment.

If a business wants to put a self-billing arrangement in place it does not have to tell HMRC or get approval from them, but it does have to get its supplier or customer to agree to the arrangement and meet certain conditions.

The main advantage of self-billing is that it usually makes invoicing easier if the customer (rather than the supplier) determines the value of the purchase after the goods have been delivered or the services supplied. This could apply more in certain areas such as; royalties, the construction industry, Feed-In-Tariff, and scrap metal. A further benefit is that accounting staff will be working with uniform purchase documentation.

However, there is a high risk of errors, significant confusion and audit trail weaknesses. The wrong rate of VAT may easily be applied, documents can go missing, invoices may be raised as well as self-billing documents, the conditions for using self-billing may easily be breached (a common example is a supplier deregistering from VAT) and essential communication between the parties can be overlooked. As the Tribunal chairman in UDL Construction Plc observed: “I regard the self-billing procedure as a gross violation of the integrity of the VAT system. It permits a customer to originate a document which enables him to recover input tax and obliges his supplier to account for output tax. It goes without saying that such a dangerous procedure should be strictly controlled and policed.”

The rules

For the customer

You can set up self-billing arrangements with your suppliers as long as you can meet certain conditions, you’ll need to:

Enter into an agreement with each supplier
Review agreements with suppliers at regular intervals
Keep records of each of the suppliers who let you self-bill them
Make sure invoices contain the right information and are correctly issued. This means including all of the details that make up a full VAT invoice – details here

If a supplier stops being registered for VAT then you can continue to self-bill them, but you can’t issue them with VAT invoices (and you cannot claim any input tax). Your self-billing arrangement with that supplier is no longer covered by the VAT regulations.

The Agreement

A self-billing arrangement is only valid if your supplier agrees to put one in place. If you don’t have an agreement with your supplier your self-billed invoices won’t be valid VAT invoices – and you won’t be able to reclaim the input tax shown on them.

You’ll both need to sign a formal self-billing agreement. This is a legally binding document. The agreement must contain:

Your supplier’s agreement that you, as the self-biller, can issue invoices on your supplier’s behalf
Your supplier’s confirmation that they won’t issue VAT invoices for goods or services covered by the agreement
An expiry date – usually for 12 months’ time but it could be the date that any business contract you have with your supplier ends
Your supplier’s agreement that they’ll let you know if they stop being registered for VAT, get a new VAT registration number or transfer their business as a going concern
Details of any third party you intend to outsource the self-billing process to.

An example of an agreement here

Reviewing self-billing agreements

Self-billing agreements usually last for 12 months. At the end of this you’ll need to review the agreement to make sure you can prove to HMRC that your supplier agrees to accept the self-billing invoices you issue on their behalf. It’s very important that you don’t self-bill a supplier when you don’t have their written agreement to do so.

Records

If you are a self-biller you’ll need to keep certain additional records:

Copies of the agreements you make with your suppliers
The names, addresses and VAT registration numbers of the suppliers who have agreed that you can self-bill them

If you don’t keep the required records, then the self-billed invoices you issue won’t be proper VAT invoices.

Invoices

Once a self-billing agreement is in place with a supplier, you must issue self-billed invoices for all the transactions with them during the period of the agreement.

As well as all the details that must go on a full VAT invoice you will also need to include your supplier’s:

name
address
VAT registration number

All self-billed invoices must include the statement “The VAT shown is your output tax due to HMRC” and you must clearly mark each self-billed invoice you raise with the reference: ‘Self Billing’ (This rule has the force of law). Details required on invoice here

Input tax

You’ll only be able to reclaim the input tax shown on self-billed invoices if you meet all the record keeping requirements. When you can reclaim the input tax depends on the date when the supply of the goods or services takes place for VAT purposes. This is known as the the tax point, details here

For the supplier

If one of your customers wants to set up a self-billing arrangement with you, they will be required to agree to this with you in writing. If you agree, they’ll give you a self-billing agreement to sign.

The terms of the agreement are a matter between you and your customer, but there are certain conditions you’ll both have to meet to make sure you comply with VAT regulations:

Sign and keep a copy of the self-billing agreement
Agree not to issue any sales invoices to your customer for any transaction during the period of the agreement
Agree to accept the self-billing invoices that your customer issues
Tell your customer at once if you change your VAT registration number, deregister from VAT, or transfer your business as a going concern.

Accounting for output tax

The VAT figure on the self-billed invoice your customer sends you is your output tax.

You are accountable to HMRC for output tax on the supplies you make to your customer, so you should check that your customer is applying the correct rate of VAT on the invoices they send you. If there has been a VAT rate change, you will need to check that the correct rate has been used.

Tips

As a supplier, take care not to treat self-billed invoices as purchase invoices and reclaim the VAT shown as input tax
As a customer, carry out an instant check of VAT registration numbers here
As a supplier or customer regularly check that the conditions for self-billing continue to be met and ensure good communications
As a supplier or customer ensure that the documentation accurately reflects the relevant transactions and the correct VAT rate is applied
As a supplier or customer ensure that there is a clear audit trial and that all documentation is available for HMRC inspection
It is possible to use self-billing cross-border intra-EC, but additional rules apply.

VAT – New road fuel scale charges from 1 May 2016

By Marcus Ward 22 March 2016

If a VAT registered business purchases fuel for business use of its vehicles, but there is also private use of cars and other vehicles, an adjustment is required to ensure no VAT is claimed on the private consumption of fuel. This is called the VAT fuel scale charge

To make accounting for VAT on private use of fuel by car drivers a business may apply a VAT fuel scale charge, this adds back a fixed sum, per VAT period, to account of private consumption of fuel.

The scale charge is calculated according to a car’s CO2 emissions and the charge is added to Output VAT it reflects a charge for the private use of the fuel. The road fuel scale charges are amended at each Budget. The new rates come into effect from 1 May 2016 and may be found here

Businesses must use the new scale charges from the start of the next prescribed accounting period beginning on or after 1 May 2016.

Other Budget changes

Apart from the VAT registration limit being raised by £1,000 to £83,000 and the deregistration limit has been increased to £81,000 both with effect 1 April 2016, there were few VAT changes in the budget.

VAT Latest from the courts – importance of invoicing requirements

By Marcus Ward 16 March 2016

In the recent case of Gradon Construction Ltd the validity of invoices was considered and whether input tax could be recovered in respect of them.

HMRC disallowed a claim for input tax on the basis that the supplier had retrospectively deregistered on a date prior to the date shown on the invoices. The Tribunal decided that this was not a reason to disallow the claim. However, it decided that the claim should be disallowed on the grounds that the invoices did not contain a description sufficient to identify the goods or services supplied, nor did they provide the quantity of the goods or the extent of the services as required by legislation. Consequently, the documents did not meet the requirements of a valid tax invoice with the result that the recipient could not recover the amount on the documents which purported to be VAT. HMRC has the discretion to accept alternative evidence in lieu of an invoice, but in this case the Tribunal decided that HMRC acted reasonably in not accepting any other documentation, so the recipient of the supply could not recover the input tax.

This case again highlights the crucial importance of primary documentation when it comes to VAT. A full guide to invoices here

Information on input tax that it is not possible to claim here https://www.marcusward.co/what-vat-cant-you-claim-2/

It is crucial that a business’ invoices meet all the requirements, and that a procedure is in place to check the validity of invoices received in order to determine whether the input tax is claimable, or whether the invoice issuer should be contacted so that a valid tax invoice may be obtained.

Latest from the courts – More on VAT on food and drink

By Marcus Ward 14 March 2016

OK, so most people are aware of the Jaffa Cake case and the appeals relating to smoothies and the VAT oddities that are thrown up by chocolate foods and fruit drinks. The latest in what many view to be a ridiculous situation is the Nestlé UK Limited case concerning Nesquik powder.

Nestlé appealed against HMRC’s decision not to repay over £4 million in VAT accounted for on the sale of strawberry and banana flavoured Nesquik powder. Nestlé formed the view that the powder which is used to flavour milk, should be zero rated in the same way that the chocolate flavoured powder and ready to drink milk based drinks it produces are.

The First Tier Tribunal found in favour of HMRC and decided that the fruit flavoured powders were a “powder for the preparation of beverages” covered by the exception from zero-rating for such products and that they were not covered by the items overriding the exceptions to zero-rating, so they remained standard-rated; hence no retrospective claim for overdeclared output tax.

So, there is differing VAT treatment depending on what flavour the Nesquik powders are, and between ready to drink products and ones where the customer has to mix them his/herself.

Fortunately, VAT is completely logical and there are simply no traps for the unwary! My own view is that the legislation regarding food and drink is so convoluted and complex that it needs a complete rewriting. I appreciate that case law has caused the current situation, and this has not been helped by political tinkering (pasty tax anyone?) but clarity is long overdue. I strongly suggest that this is not the last food based case, and of course we have had them going back to the inception of VAT. Now, this chocolate hot cross bun……

Ten Questions every business should ask about VAT

By Marcus Ward 8 March 2016

1. Am I sure that a VAT inspection would not find any errors?

An inspection can result in significant assessments, penalties and interest, apart from a business becoming “known” to HMRC. Peace of mind is a valuable benefit for a business owner too!

2. Am I sure that I am reclaiming as much VAT as possible?

We often find that businesses miss out on recovering input tax, this clearly results in an actual cost.

3. Do I take full advantage all available VAT reliefs, customs exemptions and duty refund schemes?

Failure to do so will create a tax cost and may be putting a business in a less competitive position.

4. Am I up to date on the indirect tax developments in my key markets?

Indirect tax changes rapidly, and so does the market place. Being unaware of changes that affect you may result in VAT being overpaid, or penalties being levied if you have underdeclared tax. It may also put you at a competitive disadvantage.

5. Have I considered the impact of tax rate changes on my pricing and margin, and have I taken the necessary measures?

Budgeting is affected by VAT. Failure to consider indirect taxes may eat into profit.

6. Do I collect all the data about my customers and transactions that could be required by tax authorities?

As in many VAT circumstances, getting it wrong or missing something results in penalties.

7. Do I comply with all indirect tax requirements in the jurisdictions where I operate or where my customers belong?

VAT and GST does exist outside the UK and ignoring overseas indirect tax obligations may result in action being taken by foreign authorities which will prove to be very uncomfortable and expensive. It is important to understand the rules for indirect tax in each country/area you trade. Don’t get caught out.

8. Do I have the tools to analyse my indirect tax flows and data?

Allocating sufficient technical and human resources to VAT is important. Seeking professional advice at the appropriate time is also prudent.

9. Could changes in the way my business is structured or how transactions are organised improve my indirect tax position and/or reduce complexity?

Saving money and reducing tax complications must be near the top of every business’ wish list. Seeking professional advice on structuring a business or a transaction goes a long way to achieving this

10. Is my business using the right VAT scheme?

There are many special schemes that a business may use, from the Flat Rate Scheme to Margin Schemes. Most are optional, but some, like the Tour Operators’ Margin Scheme are compulsory. Choose the wrong one, or being unaware of a beneficial scheme could cost.

It is important to constantly monitor a business’ VAT position. The nature of trade changes, technology changes, case law changes and the VAT rules are constantly in a state of flux. It is easy to assume that everything is alright because it has always been done that way, but there may be significant exposures and missed opportunities out there. We offer services from a basic healthcheck to a full technical review. A review will let you rest easy in your bed if nothing else!