Tag Archives: vat-planning

VAT – How To Survive The Enforcement Powers

By   19 January 2016
0

Penalties for VAT infringements are draconian and there is still an alarming array of enforcement powers to trap the unwary. By being conscious of the problem areas and planning carefully, it should be possible to avoid becoming an unwitting victim of the system. This article focuses mainly on VAT compliance.

Late Registration

You must notify HMRC if your turnover exceeds £82,000 in twelve months, or if you believe it will exceed £82,000 in the next thirty days.  The penalty for failing to notify liability falls within the single penalty system and it could be up to 100% of the VAT due.  There is no penalty if the taxpayer has a reasonable excuse for not registering at the correct time.

After Registration

Every VAT registered business needs to ensure that it is organised to deal with VAT correctly and on time:

  • Is there someone in your business who controls VAT accounting and ensures that new products etc. are properly dealt with for VAT purposes?
  • Do your business systems ensure that all output tax and input tax are properly recorded?
  • Are systems in force to ensure that proper evidence is obtained to support VAT input tax claims?
  • Where VAT is not charged on supplies made, is this correct in law and is proper evidence retained?
  • Are there systems in force to ensure that non‐deductible input tax is not reclaimed, e.g. most VAT on motor cars, or business entertaining?
  • Is VAT always considered before contracts are made?

Default surcharge

A default occurs if HMRC has not received your return and all the VAT due by the due date. The relevant date is the date that cleared funds reach HMRC’s bank account. If the due date is not a working day, payment must be received on the last preceding working day.  .

Consequence of default

You receive a warning after the first default ‐ the Surcharge Liability Notice (SLN). Do not ignore this notice. If you fail to pay the VAT due on the due date within the next five quarters, the surcharge will be 2% of the outstanding tax. The surcharge increases to 5% for the next default, and then by 5% increments to a maximum of 15%.  Each default, whether it is late submission of the return or late payment, extends the surcharge liability period, but only late payment incurs a surcharge.

Errors on returns and claims

Incorrect returns incur a penalty under the following penalties apply:

  • An error, when reasonable care not taken: 30%;
  • An error which is deliberate, but not concealed: 70%;
  • An error, which is deliberate and concealed: 100%.

If a taxpayer takes ‘reasonable care,’ then no penalty is due.

More on errors here

Retention of records

The period for retaining records is six years. There is a fixed penalty of £500 for breaching this requirement.

Default interest

  • Interest on tax will arise in certain circumstances, including cases where:
  • An assessment is made to recover extra tax for a period for which a return has already been made (this includes errors voluntarily disclosed)
  • A person has failed to notify his or her liability to register (or made late notification), and an assessment covering a period longer than three months is made to recover the tax due
  • An invoice purporting to include VAT has been issued by a person not authorised to issue tax invoices.

The rate of interest is set by the Treasury and is broadly in line with commercial rates of interest.

Appeals

Appeals against penalties may be made to the independent tribunal. The tribunal has powers of mitigation in appropriate circumstances. Where the appeal is against the imposition of interest, penalties, or surcharge, the tax must be paid before an appeal can be heard. The tribunal is given the authority to increase assessments that are established as being for amounts less than they should have been.

Access to information

HMRC has extensive powers to obtain information. It can enter premises and gain access to computerised systems and remove documents. A walking possession agreement can arise where distress is levied against a person’s goods.

The sting in the tail

None of the above penalties or interest is allowable as a deduction when computing income for corporation or income tax purposes.

Action points

If you receive a VAT assessment (because you have not submitted a return), you must check it and notify HMRC within thirty days if it understates your liability

Make sure your systems and records are adequate to enable you to establish the gross amount of tax relating to a VAT period. The preparation of annual accounts cannot be regarded as a safeguard against penalties

Make sure you get your VAT return and payment in on time.

Some of these penalties may not apply if there is a reasonable excuse, but the scope is limited and should not be relied upon

If in doubt, contact us. It is important that you seek professional advice as early as possible.

VAT Flat Rate Scheme (FRS)– New judgement on retrospective application

By   14 January 2016
0

Latest from the courts

In the recent case of KDT Management Ltd an appeal against a decision by HMRC not to allow the appellant to retrospectively apply the percentage of turnover it says was appropriate to its business under the FRS instead of the one it says it mistakenly chose was considered.

HMRC issued an assessment to recover VAT which was alleged to have been omitted from the appellant’s returns because it did not apply certain increases of rate to its turnover under the FRS of accounting for VAT.

It was also an appeal against a decision by HMRC not to allow the appellant to retrospectively apply the percentage of turnover it says was appropriate to its business under the FRS instead of the one it says it mistakenly chose.

The decision was that the appeal against the assessments to VAT and interest were upheld.  The appeal against the decision not to backdate was also upheld and the decision was cancelled.

Please contact us if you have been in dispute over the rate applicable on a FRS, or if you think you may be using an inappropriate percentage. This is likely to mainly affect small businesses.

Details of the FRS here

Small business: Should I register for VAT voluntarily?

By   12 January 2016
0

OK, so why would a business choose to VAT register when it need not (let’s say it’s turnover is under the VAT registration limit of £82,000)?  Isn’t it best just to avoid the VATman if at all possible?

This is not an article which considers whether a business MUST register, but rather it looks at whether it is a good idea to register on a voluntary basis if it is not compulsory.

As a general rule of thumb; if you sell to the public (B2C) then probably not.  If you sell to other VAT registered businesses (B2B) then it is more likely to be beneficial.

If you sell B2B to customers overseas it is almost certain that VAT registration would be a good thing, as it would if you supply zero rated goods or services in the UK.  This is because there is no output tax on sales, but full input tax recovery on costs; VAT nirvana!  A distinction must be made between zero rated supplies and exempt supplies.  If only exempt supplies are made, a business cannot register for VAT.

Apart from the economic considerations, we have found that small businesses are sometimes put off  VAT registration by the added compliance costs and the potential penalties being in the VAT club can bring.  Weighed against this, there is a certain kudos or prestige for a business and it does convey a degree of seriousness of a business undertaking. It may also make life simpler (and reduce costs) if a business buys goods or services from other EC Member States.  We also come across situations where a customer will only deal with suppliers who are VAT registered.

The key to registration is that, once registered, a business may recover the VAT it incurs on its expenditure (called input tax).  So let us look at some simple examples of existing businesses for comparison:

Example 1

A business sells office furniture to other VAT registered business (B2B).

It buys stock for 10,000 plus VAT of 2,000

It incurs VAT on overheads (rent, IT, telephones, light and heat etc) of 2,000 plus 400 VAT

It makes sales of 20,000.

If not registered, its profit is 20,000 less 12,000 less 2400 = 5600

If VAT registered, the customer can recover any VAT charged, so VAT is not a disincentive to him.

Sales 20,000 plus 4000 VAT (paid to HMRC)

Input tax claimed = 2400 (offset against payment to HMRC)

Result: the VAT is neutral and not a cost, so profit is 20,000 less 12,000 = 8000, a saving of 2400 as compared to the business not being registered.  The 2400 clearly equals the input tax recovered on expenditure.

Example 2

A “one-man band consultant” provides advice B2B and uses his home as his office.  All of his clients are able to recover any VAT charged.

He has very little overheads that bear VAT as most of his expenditure is VAT free (staff, train fares, use of home) so his input tax amounts to 100.

He must weigh up the cost (time/admin etc) of VAT registration against reclaiming the 100 of input tax.  In this case it would probably not be worthwhile VAT registering (although the Flat Rate Scheme may be attractive, please see article here

Example 3

A retailer sells adult clothes to the public from a shop. She pays VAT on the rent and on the purchase of stock as well as the usual overheads.  The total amount she pays is 20,000 with VAT of 4000.

Her sales total 50,000.

If not VAT registered her profit is 50,000 less 24,000 = 26,000

If VAT registered she will treat the value of sales as VAT inclusive, so of the 50,000 income 8333 represents VAT she must pay to HMRC.  She is able to offset her input tax of 4000.

This means that her profit if VAT registered is 50,000 less the VAT of 8333  = 41,667 less the net costs of 20,000 = 21,667.

Result: a loss of 4333 in profit.

As may be seen, if a business sells to the public it is nearly always disadvantageous to be voluntarily VAT registered. It may be possible to increase her prices by circa 20%, but for a lot of retailers, this is unrealistic.

Intending traders

If a business has not started trading, but is incurring input tax on costs, it is possible to VAT register even though it has not made any taxable supplies.  This is known by HMRC as an intending trader registration.  A business will need to provide evidence of the intention to trade and this is sometimes a stumbling block, especially in the area of land and property.  Choosing to register before trading may avoid losing input tax due to the time limits (very generally a business can go back six months for services and four years for goods on hand to recover the VAT).  Also cashflow will be improved if input tax is recovered as soon as possible.

Action

Careful consideration should be given to the VAT status of a small or start-up business.  This may be particularly relevant to start-ups as they typically incur more costs as the business begins and the recovery of the VAT on these costs may be important.

This is a basic guide and there are many various situations that require further consideration of the benefits of voluntary VAT registration.  We would, of course, be pleased to help.

UK VAT Registration For Overseas Businesses – A Guide

By   5 January 2016
0

2013-12-01 Bury St Eds Xmas Fair0018 (2)When must an overseas business register for VAT in the UK?

This question is increasingly being asked by overseas entities which do business in the UK.  So what are the requirements, and what choices are there?

 Compliance

An overseas business must VAT register in the UK if:

 • it makes any taxable supplies of goods and services in the UK in the course of furtherance of his business. These supplies could be of any description, but commonly are the sale of goods which are physically located in the UK and the operation of certain events that take place in the UK.

• the business is registered for VAT in another EC country, and it sells and delivers goods in the UK to customers who are not VAT-registered;so-called ‘distance sales’  (details here) and the value of those distance sales exceeds the relevant threshold (currently £70,000).

• it acquires goods in the UK directly from a VAT-registered supplier in another EC country and the total value of the acquisitions exceeds the acquisitions threshold.

• it makes a claim under the EC 8th Directive or EC 13th Directive and subsequently supplies the relevant goods in the UK.

If these tests are met, a supply is made in the UK. It does not matter in which country where the business “belongs” or where it’s staff or technical resources are located.  A guide to the place of belonging  here.

For VAT purposes, the UK includes the territorial sea of the UK (ie waters within twelve nautical miles of the coastline).

There is no need to register if the only UK supplies are those on which the customer is liable to account for any VAT due under the ‘reverse charge’ procedure.

An overseas trader may also be registered if:

• he has started in business but is not yet making taxable supplies, provided he can show the intention of making taxable supplies in the future as part of his business; or

• his turnover is below the threshold, provided he can prove to HMRC that he is carrying on a business for VAT purposes and making taxable supplies.

Consequences of registration

An overseas business which is registered or required to be registered for VAT in the UK must account for VAT in respect of those supplies and acquisitions taking place in the UK. It is also liable to VAT on imports of any goods into the UK and on the acquisition in the UK of excisable goods or of new means of transport from another EC country. It also usually means that any VAT incurred in the UK may be recovered as input tax. This is particularly relevant if import VAT is incurred on importing goods into the UK.

Registration options available 

An overseas trader who is not normally resident in the UK, does not have a UK establishment and, in the case of a company, is not incorporated here, and which is required or entitled to be registered in the UK can normally choose between three registration options:

(1) It may appoint a VAT representative who will be jointly and severally liable for any VAT debts. The overseas trader must still complete a VAT registration form. In addition to this, both the overseas trader and the VAT representative must complete a Form VAT 1TR. It is understood that, in practice, very few businesses are prepared to provide the services of a VAT representative because they are unwilling to become liable for any VAT debts of the overseas trader.

(2) It may appoint an agent to deal with the VAT affairs. The agent cannot be held responsible to HMRC for any VAT debts and HMRC reserve the right not to deal with any particular agent. (In some cases, HMRC could insist that a tax representative is appointed although this cannot now be done where the overseas trader is based in a country where certain mutual assistance arrangements exist.) The overseas trader must still complete a VAT registration form. In addition, HMRC will need a letter of authority. A suggested letter of authority approved by HMRC is:

(Insert principal’s name) of (insert principal’s address) hereby appoints (insert name of UK agent or employee) of (insert address of UK agent or employee) to act as agent for the purpose of dealing with all their legal obligations in respect of Value Added Tax. 

This letter authorises the above-named agent to sign VAT return forms 100 and any other document needed for the purpose of enabling the agent or employee to comply with the VAT obligations of the principal. 

Signed (insert principal’s signature) 

Date (insert date) 

(3) It may deal with all the VAT obligations (including registration, returns and record-keeping) itself. To register, the overseas business should contact the Aberdeen VAT office at Ruby House, 8 Ruby Place, Aberdeen, AB10 1ZP (Tel: 01224 404807/818). This is known as a Non-Established Taxable Person (NETP) registration.

Summary

There can be confusion around this matter, not only from a technical aspect, but with an overseas business’ unfamiliarity with the UK authority’s requirements and also possibly language and communication problems.  Additionally, the practical aspects of identifying the need to VAT register in the UK and the completion of forms etc can delay matters.  Of course, just like any other VAT registration, there are penalties for not registering, or not registering at the appropriate time.  There is also the reluctance of certain overseas businesses to deal with UK VAT at all.  Unfortunately, a head in the sand attitude just stores up problems for the future.  We have been called on to firefight on this topic a number of times, and it rarely ends well.

VAT – Building your new home. Claiming VAT on costs

By   14 December 2015
0

Building your own home is becoming increasingly popular.  There are many things to think about, and budgeting is one of the most important.

The recovery of VAT on the project has a huge impact on the budget and care must be taken to ensure that a claim is made properly and within the time limits.  You don’t have to be VAT registered to make a claim, this is done via a mechanism known as The DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme.  It has specific rules which must be adhered to otherwise the claim will be rejected.

If you buy a new house from a property developer, you will not be charged VAT. This is because the sale of the house to you will be zero-rated. This allows the developer to reclaim the VAT paid on building materials from HMRC. However, if you build a house yourself, you will not be able to benefit from the zero-rating. The DIY Housebuilder’ Scheme puts you in a similar position to a person who buys a zero-rated house built by a property developer.

Who can make a claim?

You can apply for a VAT refund on building materials and services if you are:

  • building a new home in which you will live
  • converting a building into a home
  • building a non-profit communal residence, eg; a hospice
  • building a property for a charity.

Eligibility

New homes

The house must:

  • be separate and self-contained (eg; not an extension)
  • be for you or your family to live or holiday in (not for sale when complete)
  • not be for business purposes (you can use one room as a work from home office)
  • not be prevented from sale independently to another building by planning permission or similar (eg; a granny annexe).

A claim may also be made for garages built at the same time as the house and to be used with the house.

Contractors working on new residential buildings should zero rate their supplies to you, so you won’t pay any VAT on these.

Conversions

The building being converted must usually be a non-residential building (eg; a barn conversion). Residential also buildings qualify if they haven’t been lived in for at least 10 years.

You may claim a refund for builders’ work on a conversion of non-residential building into home. These supplies will be charged at the reduced rate of 5% for conversion works.  If the standard rate of 20% s charged incorrectly, you will not be able to claim the standard rated amount. Care should be taken that the contractor understands the VAT rules for conversions as these can be complex.

Communal and charity buildings

You may get a VAT refund if the building is for one of the following purposes:

  • non-business – you can’t charge a fee for the use of the building
  • charitable, eg; a hospice
  • residential, eg; a children’s home

What can you claim on?

Building materials

You may claim a VAT refund for building materials that are incorporated into the building and can’t be removed without tools or damaging the building.

What doesn’t qualify

You cannot claim for:

  • building projects outside the UK
  • materials or services that don’t have any VAT, eg;  were zero-rated or exempt
  • professional or supervisory fees, eg architects and surveyors
  • the hire of plant, tools and equipment, eg; generators, scaffolding and skips
  • building materials that aren’t permanently attached to or part of the building itself
  • some fitted furniture, electrical and gas appliances, carpets or garden ornaments
  • supplies for which you do not have a VAT invoice

Examples of items you can, and cannot claim for are listed below.

How to claim

To claim a VAT refund, send form 431NB or 431C to HMRC

Local Compliance National DIY Team
SO987
Newcastle
NE98 1ZZ

What you need to know

You must claim within 3 months of the building work being completed.

You will usually get the refund in 30 working days of sending the claim.

You must include the following with your claim:

  • bank details
  • planning permission
  • proof the building work is finished – eg a letter from your local authority
  • a full set of building plans
  • invoices – including tenders or estimations if the invoice isn’t itemised
  • bills and any credit notes

VAT invoices must be valid and show the correct rate of VAT or they will not be accepted in the claim.

HMRC usually examine every claim closely and often query them, so it pays to ensure that the claim is as accurate as possible first time.  We find a review by us before submission ensures the maximum amount is claimed and delays are avoided.

Payments made after completion of the house cannot be claimed, and only one claim can be made for the whole project, so cashflow may be an issue.

Examples of items that you can claim for
The items listed below are accepted as being ‘ordinarily’ incorporated in a building (or its site). This is not a complete list.
  • Air conditioning
  • Building materials that make up the fabric of the property (for example, bricks, cement, tiles, timber, etc)
  • Burglar and fire alarms
  • Curtain poles and rails
  • Fireplaces and surrounds
  • Fitted kitchen furniture, sinks, and work surfaces
  • Flooring materials (other than carpets and carpet tiles)
  • Some gas and electrical appliances when wired-in or plumbed-in
  • Heating and ventilation systems including solar panels
  • Light fittings (including chandeliers and outside lights)
  • Plumbing materials, including electric showers, ‘in line’ water softeners and sanitary ware
  • Saunas
  • Turf, plants, trees (to the extent that they are detailed on scheme approved by a Planning Permission) and fencing permanently erected around the boundary of the dwelling
  • TV aerials and satellite dishes
Examples of items that you cannot claim for
This is not a complete list.
    • Aga/range cookers (Unless they are solid fuel, oil-fired or designed to heat space or water. Note: not all cookers are ‘space heaters’ because they incidentally radiate heat while operating. To be classified as such they must be fitted to a heating module or boiler)
    • Free-standing and integrated appliances such as: cookers, fridges, freezers, dishwashers, microwaves, washing machines, dryers, coffee machines
    • Audio equipment (including remote controls), built-in speakers, intelligent lighting systems, satellite boxes, Freeview boxes, CCTV, telephones
    • Consumables (for example, sandpaper, white spirit)
    • Electrical components for garage doors and gates (including remote controls)
    • Bedroom furniture (unless they are basic wardrobes) bathroom furniture (for example, vanity units and free-standing units)
    • Curtains, blinds (unless they are integral, that is, blinds inside sealed double-glazed window units),
    • Carpets
  • Garden furniture and ornaments and sheds. 

Please contact us if you require assistance with a DIY Housebuild project.

VAT – Well, it is christmas…

By   7 December 2015
0

Dear Marcus 2013-12-01 Bury St Eds Xmas Fair0072

My business, if that is what it is, has become large enough for me to fear that HMRC might take an interest in my activities.  May I explain what I do and then you can write to me with your advice?  If you think a face to face meeting would be better I can be found in most decent sized department stores from mid September to 24 December.

First of all I am based in Greenland but I do bring a stock of goods, mainly toys, to the UK and I distribute them.  Am I making supplies in the UK?

The toys are of course mainly for children and I wonder if zero rating might apply?  I have heard that small T shirts are zero rated so what about a train set – it is small and intended for children. Does it matter if adults play with it?

My friend Rudolph has told me that there is a peculiar rule about gifts.  He says that if I give them away regularly and they cost more than £150 I might have to account for VAT.  Is that right?

My next question concerns barter transactions.  Dads often leave me a food item such as a mince pie and a drink and there is an unwritten rule that I should then leave something in return.  If I’m given Tesco’s own brand sherry I will leave polyester underpants but if I’m left a glass of Glenfiddich I will be more generous and leave best woollen socks.  Have I made a supply and what is the value please?  My feeling is that the food items are not solicited so VAT might not be due and, in any event; isn’t food zero-rated, or is it catering? Oh, and what if the food is hot?

Transport is a big worry for me.  Lots of children ask me for a ride on my airborne transport.  I suppose I could manage to fit 12 passengers in.  Does that mean my services are zero-rated?  If I do this free of charge will I need to charge air passenger duty?  Does it matter if I stay within the UK?  My transport is the equivalent of six horse power and if I refuel with fodder in the UK will I be liable for fuel scale charges?  After dropping the passengers off I suppose I will be accused of using fuel for the private journey back home.  Somebody has told me that if I buy hay labelled as animal food I can avoid VAT but if I buy the much cheaper bedding hay I will need to pay VAT.  Please comment.

Can I also ask about VAT registration?  I know the limit is £82,000 per annum but do blips count?  If I do make supplies at all, I do nothing for 364 days and then, in one day (well night really) I blast through the limit and then drop back to nil turnover.  May I be excused from registration?  If I do need to register should I use AnNOEL Accounting?  At least I can get only one penalty per annum if I get the sums wrong.

I would like to make a claim for input tax on clothing.  I feel that my red clothing not only protects me from the extreme cold but it is akin to a uniform and should be allowable.  These are not clothes that I would choose to wear except for my fairly unusual job.  If lady barristers can claim for black skirts I think I should be able to claim for red dress.  And what about my annual haircut?  That costs a fortune.  I only let my hair grow that long because it is expected of me.

Insurance worries me too.  You know that I carry some very expensive goods on my transport.  Play Stations, Mountain Bikes, i-pads and Accrington Stanley replica shirts for example.  My parent company in Greenland takes out insurance there and they make a charge to me.  If I am required to register for VAT in England will I need to apply the reverse charge?  This seems to be a daft idea if I understand it correctly.  Does it mean I have to charge myself VAT on something that is not VATable and then claim it back again?

Next you’ll be telling me that Father Christmas isn’t real……….

VAT – The Default Surcharge. What is it, is it fair and will the regime change?

By   1 December 2015
0

What is the Default Surcharge? 

Default Surcharge is a civil penalty to encourage businesses to submit their VAT returns and pay the tax due on time.

When will a Default Surcharge be issued?

A business is in default if it sends in its VAT return and or the VAT due late. No surcharge is issued the first time a business is late but a warning (a Surcharge Liability Notice) is issued. Subsequent defaults within the following twelve months (the “surcharge period”) may result in a surcharge assessment. Each time that a default occurs the surcharge period will be extended. There is no liability to a surcharge if a nil or repayment return is submitted late, or the VAT due is paid on time but the return is submitted late (although a default is still recorded).

How much is the surcharge?

The surcharge is calculated as a percentage of the VAT that is unpaid at the due date. If no return is submitted the amount of VAT due will be assessed and the surcharge based on that amount. The rate is set at 2 per cent for the first default following the Surcharge Liability Notice, and rises to 5 per cent, 10 per cent and 15 per cent for subsequent defaults within the surcharge period.  A surcharge assessment is not issued at the 2 per cent and 5 per cent rates if it is calculated at less than £200 but a default is still recorded and the surcharge period extended. At the 10 per cent and 15 per cent the surcharge will be the greater of the calculated amount or £30.

Specific issues

The default surcharge can be particularly swingeing for a fast growing company. Let’s say that a small company grows quickly. In the early days the administration was rather haphazard, as is often the case, and a number of returns and payments were submitted late. Fast forward and the turnover, and the VAT payable, has grown significantly. Being late at this time means that the amount of default surcharge is considerably higher than when the original default which created the surcharge took place.  This leads us onto whether the surcharge is proportionate.

A business with cashflow difficulties may well ask whether it should be penalised by HMRC for having those difficulties; which of course will add to the problem.

Proportionality

The existing, long-standing default surcharge regime has always had issues with the principle of proportionality.  The regime has regularly been challenged in the Courts.

Is it proportionate that a same penalty is applied for a payment which is one day late and one which is one year late? This is a matter which has concerned both HMRC and the Courts for a number of years.

In the Upper Tribunal case of Total Technology (Engineering) Ltd the Judge concluded that it was possible for an individual surcharge to be disproportionate, but that the system as a whole was not fundamentally flawed. It is also worth noting that in In Equoland judgment the judge stated that a penalty which is automatic and does not take into account the circumstances is at the least tending towards being disproportionate.  The default surcharge is automatic and it is one of the few penalties that cannot be mitigated in any circumstances.

Defence against a surcharge

In order to have a surcharge withdrawn it is necessary to demonstrate that a business had a reasonable excuse for the default.  

This is a subject of an article on its own.  Certain factors, like relaying on a third party are not accepted as a reasonable excuse. HMRC state that a business will not be in default if they, or the independent tribunal, agree that there is a reasonable excuse for failing to submit a VAT Return and/or payment on time.

There is no legal definition of reasonable excuse but HMRC will look closely at the circumstances that led to the default.

If the circumstance that led to the default were unforeseen and inescapable and a business is able to show that its conduct was that of a conscientious person who accepted the need to comply with VAT requirements, then it may amount to a reasonable excuse.

What sort of circumstances might count as reasonable excuse?

HMRC provide guidelines on circumstances where there might be a reasonable excuse for failing to submit a VAT Return and/or payment on time. These include:

  • computer breakdown
  • illness
  • loss of key personnel
  • unexpected cash crisis – where funds are unavailable to pay your tax due following the sudden reduction or withdrawal of overdraft facilities, sudden non-payment by a normally reliable customer, insolvency of a large customer, fraud or burglary. A simple lack of money is unlikely to be accepted as a reasonable excuse.
  • loss of records

Latest

A recent discussion document sought views from businesses and individuals on potential improvements to how HMRC applies penalties (including the default surcharge) for failing to pay what is owed or to meet deadlines for returns or registration.

HMRC is considering whether and how it should differentiate between those who deliberately and persistently fail to meet administrative deadlines or to pay what they should on time, and those who make occasional and genuine errors for which other responses might be more appropriate.

In the document HMRC highlight two issues with the current VAT default surcharge regime. The first is the concern that while the absence of penalty for the initial offence in a 12 month period gives business the chance to get processes right, some customers simply ignore this warning.

The second concern is the issue of proportionality which fails to distinguish between payments that are one or two days late or many months late.

In my view, it is likely that in the near future we will hear proposals for the system being amended.  I think we may anticipate the introduction of mitigation and suspension.

VAT Sixth Form Colleges – Changes

By   25 November 2015
0

In today’s Autumn Statement, the Chancellor announced that Sixth Form Colleges will be able to convert to academies.

This means that colleges which do convert will need to review their VAT position.  There are immediate decisions to make on how to structure and deal with VAT. This Statement is great news for colleges and there will be an immediate and ongoing VAT benefit if they become an academy.  However, as with all things VAT, there are also pitfalls. As with schools converting to academy status, it is usual that the Trustees and relevant staff will need to consider VAT for the first time.  We are able to guide academies through the VAT maze and help them maximise this new beneficial tax position. We have considerable experience in dealing with VAT and academies and advise over 50 across the country. Please contact us if these changes affect you, or you would like to discuss the implications. Please see our academy services here

Should I form a VAT Group? Pros and Cons

By   19 November 2015
0

VAT Groups

This is a very concise summary of matters that should be considered when deciding to form or disband a VAT group. rowing boats

VAT grouping is a facilitation measure by which two or more bodies corporate can be treated as a single taxable person (a single VAT registration) for VAT purposes. “Bodies Corporate” includes; companies of all types and limited liability partnerships.

It is important to recognise the difference between a corporate group and a VAT group – these are two different things and it should not be assumed that a corporate group is automatically a VAT group.

There are detailed rules on who can VAT group, which is an article in itself for another day, but it is worth remembering that it is possible to VAT group where no taxable supplies are made outside the group.

Pros

  • Only one VAT return per quarter – less administration.
  • The representative member accounts for any tax due on supplies made by the group to third parties outside the group. This is particularly helpful if your accounting is centralised
  • No VAT on supplies between VAT group members. No need to invoice etc, or recognise supplies on VAT return.
  • Usually improves the partial exemption position if exempt supplies are made between group companies.
  • May improve input tax recovery if taxable supplies are made to a partly exempt group company.
  • If assets are hived up or down into a group company before a company sale to a non-grouped third party, the VAT consequences of the intra-group movement may be ignored.
  • May provide useful planning opportunities/convenience at a later date.
  • Sales invoices issued, or purchase invoices received, in the wrong company name would not require time-consuming amendment.
  • There may be cashflow benefits in respect of intra-group charges.
  • Reduced chance of penalties on intra-group charges.

 Cons

  • All members of the group are jointly and severally liable for any VAT due.
  • Former VAT group members are also liable for any VAT debts due during the period of VAT group membership.
  • Only one partial exemption de-minimis limit for group – which decreases the ability to fully recover input tax.
  • Obtaining all relevant data to complete one return may take time thus possibly missing filing deadlines.
  • A new VAT number is issued.
  • The representative member needs all of the necessary information to submit a VAT return for the group by the due date.
  • Via anti-avoidance provisions, assessments can be raised on the representative member relating to earlier periods when it was not the representative member and even when it was not a member of the group at that time.
  • The limit for voluntary disclosures of errors on past returns applies to the group as a whole (rather than each company having its own limit).
  • The payments on account (POA) limits apply to the group as a whole. This applies to a business whose VAT liability is more than £2 million pa. This adversely affects a business’s cashflow.
  • The cash accounting limit of £1,350,000 applies to the group as a whole (rather than each company having its own limit).
  • Transfers of Going Concerns (TOGCs) acquired by a partly exempt VAT group may result in an irrecoverable VAT charge as a result of a deemed self-supply.
  • An option to tax made by a VAT group member is binding on all present and future members of the VAT group. This is so even after a company has left the VAT group.

We strongly recommend that professional advice is taken when a business is either considering forming a VAT group, or when thought is being given to disbanding one. Making the wrong decision could be very expensive indeed.  Specific matters that dictate VAT advice are when:

  • property is involved
  • inter-company charges are made
  • TOGCs are involved
  • costs in respect of restructuring are incurred (a current hot potato in the courts)
  • there is an international aspect to a group
  • a reverse charge applies
  • a company has been involved in the penalty regime
  • companies become insolvent
  • a VAT group is subject to POA
  • a company, or the VAT group, makes exempt supplies.

VAT – Where do I belong?!

By   16 November 2015
0
The concept of “belonging” is very important in VAT as it determines where a supply takes place and thus the rate applicable and the country in which is due. (The so-called “Place Of Supply, or POS). It is necessary, for most supplies, to establish where both the supplier, and the recipient belongs. Because this is a complex area of VAT it is not difficult to be overpaying tax in one country, not paying tax where it is properly due, or missing the tax issue completely. 

A relevant business person `belongs’ in the relevant country. A `relevant country’ means:

  •  the country in which the person has a business establishment, or some other fixed establishment (if it has none in any other country);
  •  if the person has a business establishment, or some other fixed establishment or establishments, in more than one country, the country  of the relevant establishment (ie; the establishment most directly concerned with the supply); and
  •  otherwise, the country of the person’s usual place of residence (in the case of a body corporate, where it is legally constituted).

A person who is not a relevant business person `belongs’ in the country of his usual place of residence. The `belonging’ definition applies equally to the recipient of a supply, where relevant.

Business establishment is not defined in the legislation but is taken by HMRC to mean the principal place of business. It is usually the head office, headquarters or ‘seat’ from which the business is run. There can only be one such place and it may take the form of an office, showroom or factory.

Fixed establishment is not defined in the legislation but is taken by HMRC to mean an establishment (other than the business establishment) which has both the technical and human resources necessary for providing and receiving services on a permanent basis. A business may therefore have several fixed establishments, including a branch of the business or an agency. A temporary presence of human and technical resources does not create a fixed establishment in the UK.

Usual place of residence. A body corporate has its usual place of residence where it is legally constituted. The usual place of residence of an individual is not defined in the legislation. HMRC interpret the phrase according to the ordinary usage of the words, ie; normally the country where the individual has set up home with his/her family and is in full-time employment. An individual is not resident in a country if only visiting as a tourist.

More than one establishment. Where the supplier/recipient has establishments in more than one country, the supplies made from/received at each establishment must be considered separately. For each supply of services, the establishment which is actually providing/receiving the services is normally the one most directly connected with the supply but all facts should be considered including

  •  for suppliers, from which establishment the services are actually provided;
  •  for recipients, at which establishment the services are actually consumed, effectively used or enjoyed;
  •  which establishment appears on the contracts, correspondence and invoices;
  •  where directors or others who entered into the contract are permanently based; and
  •  at which establishment decisions are taken and controls are exercised over the performance of the contract.

However, where an establishment is actually providing/receiving the supply of services, it is normally that establishment which is most directly connected with the supply, even if the contractual position is different.

VAT groups

A VAT group is treated as a single entity. This also applies when applying the ‘place of belonging’. As a result, a group has establishments wherever any member of the group has establishments.

This is an area which often leads to uncertainty, and therefore VAT issues.  It is also an area where VAT planning may; save time, resources and avoid unexpected VAT costs, either in the UK or another country.

For more on our International Services