Category Archives: Border Control

VAT Implications of Transfer Pricing – Valuation

By Marcus Ward 21 April 2022

When can Transfer Pricing (TP) adjustments affect the application of VAT?

There is a continuing potential conflict between the way sales are valued. For TP purposes value is determined via arm’s length (open market value) versus the subjective value, ie; the price actually paid, for VAT purposes.

More detail on VAT valuation/consideration here.

Transfer Pricing

The arm’s length principle is the international transfer pricing standard that the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) member countries have agreed, and which should be used for tax purposes by Multinational Enterprise Group (“MNE group”) and tax administrations, including the price, match comparable market conditions and that profits are fairly divided between the jurisdictions in which MNE operates.

According to the OECD TP Guidelines, by seeking to adjust profits by reference to the conditions which would have been obtained between independent enterprises for comparable transactions and under comparable circumstances, ie; in “comparable uncontrolled transactions” the arm’s length principle treats the members of an MNE group as entities operating separately rather than as inseparable parts of a single unified business. Because the separate entity approach treats the members of an MNE group as if they were independent entities, attention is focused on the nature of the transactions between those members and on whether the conditions thereof differ from those that would be obtained in comparable uncontrolled transactions.

VAT

It is not generally required for VAT purposes that the consideration which must be present in order for a transaction to be qualified as taxable, has to reflect the market value of the goods or services supplied. In fact, as to the concept of “consideration”, it is settled case law of the CJEU that the taxable amount for the supply of goods or services is represented by the consideration actually received for them.

It is an important area of tax and I recommend reading the EC Working Paper for any business or adviser involved in international supplies. It is also an interesting read for students of the tax technical side of such supplies.

We have a strong global structure of skilled advisers which are able to assist if you have any queries.

VAT: Fulfilment House Due Diligence Scheme registered businesses list

By Marcus Ward 16 February 2022

HMRC has issued updated guidance for businesses which need to check whether an entity which stores goods in the UK on its behalf is registered with the Fulfilment House Due Diligence Scheme (FHDDS).

The published list is alphabetical order by company name.

The list should be used if you are a business that is not established in the EU to see if the business that stores your goods in the UK is registered with the FHDDS.

If your business is outsourcing or considering outsourcing its fulfilment operations, then the fulfilment house you are using or intending to use of must be legally accredited by HMRC to do so.

Businesses that must be registered

Businesses are required to be registered if it stores any goods where all of the following apply:

the goods were imported from a country outside the EU
the goods are owned by, or stored on behalf of, someone established outside the EU
the goods are being offered for sale and have not been sold in the UK before

It is illegal to operate outside of the scheme and any fulfilment company found doing so will be prevented operating a fulfilment business and may be subject to a £10,000 penalty and a criminal conviction.

VAT: Trading with the EU from 1 January 2022

By Marcus Ward 14 December 2021

Further to my article on the new changes from next year, HMRC has published information on the rules of origin for trade between the UK and EU.

The Bulletin covers the rules of origin and the forthcoming changes to the requirement for supplier declarations to support proof of origin.

VAT: HMRC – Customs changes from 1 January and 1 July 2022

By Marcus Ward 6 December 2021

Further to my article on new procedures, HMRC has issued a reminder of customs changes that come into effect on 1 January 2022.

It is now less than a month until full controls are introduced.

The Changes

Customs declarations

Businesses will no longer be able to delay making import customs declarations under the Staged Customs Controls Most importers will have to make declarations and pay relevant tariffs at the point of import.

Border controls

Ports and other border locations will be required to control goods moving Great Britain and the EU. This means that unless goods have a valid declaration and have received customs clearance, they will not be able to be released into circulation, and in most cases will not be able to leave the port. From 1 January 2022, goods may be directed to an Inland Border Facility for documentary or physical checks if these checks cannot be done at the border.

Rules of origin for imports and exports

The UK’s deal called the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA), means that the goods imported or exported may benefit from a reduced rate of Customs Duty (tariff preference). To use this a business will need proof that goods which are:

. imported from the EU originate there

. exported to the EU originate in the UK

Commodity codes

Commodity codes are used worldwide to classify goods that are imported and exported. They are standardised up to six digits and reviewed by the World Customs Organisation every five years. Following the end of the latest review, the UK codes will be changing on 1 January 2022. HMRC guidance is available on finding commodity codes for imports into or exports out of the UK which includes information on using the ‘Trade Tariff Tool’ to find the correct commodity codes.

Postponed VAT Accounting

A VAT registered importer is able to continue to use Postponed VAT Accounting (PVA) on all customs declarations that are liable to import VAT (including supplementary declarations).

Further changes from 1 July 2022

The following changes will be introduced from July 2022:

requirements for full safety and security declarations for all imports
new requirements for Export Health Certificates
requirements for Phytosanitary Certificates
physical checks on sanitary and phytosanitary goods at Border Control Posts

Businesses must be prepared for these changes and I recommend that an experienced representative is used.

VAT: Trading with the EU. Changes from 1 January 2022

By Marcus Ward 23 November 2021

From 1 January 2022 the rules for selling to, and buying from, the EU will change.

HMRC have issued information about these changes.

Broadly, from 1‌‌ ‌January‌‌ ‌2022, businesses will no longer be able to delay making import customs declarations under the Staged Customs Controls rules that have applied during 2021. Most businesses will have to make declarations and pay relevant tariffs at the point of import. However, see details of Postponed Accounting.

Please also see a publication issued by the Cabinet Office which includes a Policy Paper on The Border Operating Model.

VAT: Freeports – what are they? Are they beneficial?

By Marcus Ward 12 October 2021

Further to the background to Freeports here I consider the latest developments.

What are Freeports?

Freeports are a specific port where normal tax and customs rules do not apply. Imports can enter with simplified customs documentation and without paying tariffs. Businesses operating inside designated areas in and around the port can manufacture goods using the imports, before exporting again without paying the tariff on the original imported goods (however, a tariff may be payable on the finished product when it reaches its final destination).

Freeports are similar to Free zones, or “Enterprise Zones” which are designated areas subject to a broad array of special regulatory requirements, tax breaks and Government support. The difference is that a Freeport is designed to specifically encourage businesses that import, process and then re-export goods, rather than more general business support.

Use

Goods brought into a Freeport are not subject to duties until they leave the port and enter the UK market. Additionally, if the goods are re-exported no duty is payable at all.

If raw materials are brought into a Freeport and processed into final goods before entering the UK market, duties will be paid on the final goods.

Background

If a business chooses to use a Freeport to import or export goods, it will be able to:

get relief from duties and import taxes
use simplified declarations processes to reduce administrative burdens
choose which rate of Customs Duty to use if processing the goods changes their classification

If goods are purchased in the UK, a business will continue to pay duties and import taxes using the normal UK rates.

Where are they?

The eight new Freeports are located at East Midlands Airport, Felixstowe and Harwich, the Humber region, Liverpool City Region, Plymouth, the Solent, the Thames, and Teesside.

Authorisation needed to use a Freeport

A business can apply to use the Freeport customs special procedure (a single authorisation combined with easier declaration requirements) to import goods for:

processing and then export or for sale in the UK
storage and then export or for sale in the UK

Declaring goods entering the UK Freeport

A form C21 is used to declare goods entering the UK. This can be done before the goods arrive in the UK or when the goods have arrived in the UK.

Declaring goods exported

A business will normally need to submit an exit summary declaration when goods are exported from the UK. When an exit summary declaration is not needed, a business will need to give an onward export notification to HMRC.

Disposing of goods which have been processed or repaired

When a business has finished processing or repairing goods, it must leave the Freeport and dispose of the goods by either:

re-exporting them outside the UK
declaring them to another customs procedure
transferring them to another Freeport Business Authorisation holder
destroying them – usually only possible under customs supervision
using other simplified disposal methods

VAT on supplies in the Freeport

A business will be able to zero rate supplies within a Freeport of:

goods declared to the Freeport
services carried out on goods declared to the Freeport

When a zero rated VAT invoice is issued, it must include the reference “Free zone”.

Zero rating of goods applies if:

they are declared to the Freeport
they are sold from one authorised Freeport business to another in the Freeport
both Freeport businesses are registered for VAT (unless they are exempt from registering for VAT and HMRC has approved this exemption)

Benefits

The Government says that Freeports and free zones are intended to stimulate economic activity in their designated areas. Government backed economic studies have found the main advantage of Freeports is that they encourage imports by lowering duty and paperwork costs. Manufacturing businesses that are inside the Freeport can benefit from cheaper imported inputs in comparison to those outside the area. However, some commentators such as the UK Trade Policy Observatory (UKTPO) suggest that whilst some form of free zones could help with shaping export-oriented and place-based regional development programmes, it is important to ensure that trade is not simply diverted from elsewhere and that wider incentives are needed.

Evasion

Considering that the European Parliament has called for Freeports to be scrapped across the EU because of tax evasion and money laundering and that they are where trade can be conducted untaxed, and ownership can be concealed it is likely that there will be a certain degree of evasion. This a result of the lack of scrutiny on imports and means that high-value items, eg; art, can be bought and easily stored in Freeports without the kind of checks and controls they would normally face.

Summary

Any business that regularly imports and/or exports goods should consider if a Freeport will benefit their business model. This is particularly relevant if work is carried out on imported goods.

VAT: Fraudster ordered to pay £37 million

By Marcus Ward 5 August 2021

Latest from the courts

A high level fraudster who skipped his trial and fled to Dubai has been ordered to pay more than £37 million. Failure to do so will result in ten years in prison. He played a major role in this missing trader fraud (MTIC) which involves the theft of Value Added Tax from HMRC. He was part of a conspiracy to use a network of companies and a huge number of transactions to cover up the theft of VAT.

Adam Umerji, 43, was convicted in his absence of offences of conspiracy to cheat the government’s revenue and conspiracy to transfer criminal property, in a prosecution conducted by the CPS Specialist Fraud Division after a complex criminal investigation by HMRC.

Background

Missing trader fraud (also called missing trader intra-community fraud or MTIC fraud) involves the theft of VAT from a government by fraudsters who exploit VAT rules, most commonly the EU rules which provide that the movement of goods between Member States is VAT free. There are different variations of the fraud but they generally involve a trader charging VAT on the sale of goods and absconding with the VAT (instead of paying the VAT to the government’s taxation authority). The term “missing trader” is used because the fraudster has gone missing with the VAT.

A common form of missing trader fraud is carousel fraud. In carousel fraud, VAT and goods are passed around between companies and jurisdictions.

VAT: New One Stop Shop (OSS) rules from 1 July 2021

By Marcus Ward 15 June 2021

All you need to know about the new One Stop Shop (OSS)

New VAT rules will be introduced on 1 July 2021, and it is important that businesses and advisers are aware of the impact on transactions from this date. These changes have been introduced to increase the control of tax revenues as it is an area where a significant amount of tax is lost – creating an unfairness for businesses that correctly pay tax. They also aim to provide simplification for suppliers and consumers.

Who will be affected?

The new rules will impact all businesses that sell products online to consumers (B2C) in the EU, known as: distance sales. It will also affect suppliers of certain designated services and electronic interfaces.

UK online sellers not established anywhere in the EU can use the “Non-Union” version of OSS.

How OSS works

The current position

The current EU VAT rules state that cross-border sales of goods are subject to VAT in the EU Member State (MS) of dispatch. However, there are thresholds; once these sales reach a threshold in the MS of sale, a business is required to VAT register in that MS and ensure compliance and payment of VAT there.

The new rules

All sales will be subject to VAT in the MS of arrival of the goods. The existing thresholds for distance sales of goods (where the supplier is responsible for the transport of the products) within the EU will be replaced by a new EU threshold of €10,000*. To avoid a business having to VAT register in every EU MS into which it supplies goods, online sellers will be able to use the OSS electronic portal. This will enable the seller to account for, and pay, VAT in all EU MS on a single electronic quarterly return in one EU MS.

* As, since Brexit, the UK is no longer an EU MS, one the main differences is that the €10,000 annual turnover threshold for small business does not apply, so an EU VAT registration will be required for any distance sales to the EU. The business will need to nominate any single EU MS to register, submit returns, and make payments. Additionally. As a non-union OSS, depending on the chosen MS’s domestic regulations, a business may be required to appoint a fiscal representative.

Note: Even if a UK business has a turnover below the VAT registration threshold (currently £85,000 pa) so that it need not register here, it will be subject to OSS rules and need to register in an EU MS, this is compulsory.

Supplies covered by OSS

distance sales of goods within the EU by suppliers not belonging in that MS
supplies of certain B2C services (below) made by a supplier which take place in a MS in which it is not established

Services covered by Non-Union OSS

Examples of supplies of services to customers (a non-exhaustive list) that could be reported under the non-Union scheme are:

accommodation services
admission to cultural, artistic, sporting, scientific, educational, entertainment or similar events; such as fairs and exhibitions
transport services, plus ancillary activities such as; loading, unloading, handling or similar
valuation and work on movable tangible property
services connected to immovable property
hiring of means of transport
restaurant and catering services for consumption on board ships, aircraft or trains etc

Electronic interfaces

From 1 July 2021, if an electronic interface, eg; marketplace, platform, etc facilitates distance sales of goods by a non-EU established seller to a buyer in the EU, the electronic interface is considered to be the seller (“deemed supplier” rather than agent) and is liable for the payment of VAT via the OSS.

IOSS

In addition to the OSS, a new scheme covering the import of goods subject to a distance sales transaction and in consignments not exceeding €150 is being introduced to simplify accounting for VAT. This is called the Import One-Stop Shop (IOSS). If the value of the consignment exceeds €150, it will usually be the end customer who will be the importer and will have to pay VAT, and any, customs clearance etc costs.

Note: The VAT exemption at import of small consignments of a value up to €22 will be removed. This means all goods imported in the EU will now be subject to VAT.

VAT rates

Businesses will need to apply the VAT rate of the MS where the goods are dispatched to or where the services are supplied. Information on the VAT rates in the EU is available on the European Commission website.

How to register for the OSS

Each EU MS will have an online OSS portal where businesses can register from 1 April 2021 and can use for transactions made on or after 1 July 2021. The single registration will be valid for all eligible supplies made by online sellers (including electronic interfaces) or supplies facilitated by electronic interfaces.

OSS Requirements

A business that uses the OSS will be required to:

apply the VAT rate of the MS to which the goods are shipped
collect VAT from the buyer
submit a quarterly electronic VAT return
make quarterly VAT payments
keep records of all OSS supplies for ten years

Summary

The OSS is not compulsory, however, as the alternative is to VAT register in every EU MS where goods are received, it is a simplification in that respect – the previous distance selling rules were cumbersome and antiquated.

Further information

Full details of the OSS and IOSS from the EC here

New rules of origin for goods

By Marcus Ward 27 April 2021

Brexit update

HMRC has published updated, detailed guidance for the rules of origin for goods moving between the UK and EU.

It is important to understand the impact of the rules and how they impact a business. Specifically, to ensure advantage is taken of zero tariffs when dealing with cross-border goods. The rules apply to both imports and exports and clearly, incurring unnecessary tariffs is to be avoided if possible.

Background

The UK moved to trading based on a new Free Trade Agreement (FTA) – the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA) between the UK and the EU post-Brexit.

To export tariff-free under the TCA, goods must meet the UK-EU preferential rules of origin. This means that there must be a qualifying level of processing in the country of export to access zero tariffs. This applies to EU origin goods imported and moving through the UK from a Member State to another EU Member State, as well as goods imported from the Rest of World.

These rules are set out in the TCA and determine the origin of goods based on where the products or materials (or inputs) used in their production come from. Their purpose is to ensure that preferential tariffs are only given to goods that originate in the UK or EU and not from third countries.

VAT: Postponed Accounting available for Section 33 bodies

By Marcus Ward 13 April 2021

HMRC has announced that bodies covered by The VAT Act 1994, Section 33 such as; Local Authorities, Academies, Transport Authorities and the Police can use Postponed Accounting for imports.

Normally, a body cannot account for import VAT on its VAT return if it import goods that it knows will be used solely for non-business purposes. However, this no longer applies to a body that is eligible to reclaim import VAT through a VAT refund scheme (Section 33). Section 33 entities when completing its customs declaration, should select the “making an immediate payment or using a duty deferment account” option.

Section 33 bodies

These entities have special VAT treatment which is effectively the opposite of normal VAT rules. To avoid a cost to the taxpayer, these entities are permitted to specifically recover input tax that relates to non-business activities. Nobody said that VAT was straightforward and in these cases, the VAT rules are inverted!

We act for many Local Authorities and Academies. Please contact us should you, or your clients, have any queries on this matter.