Tag Archives: vat-recovery

VAT: Input tax attribution to business and non-business activities

By Marcus Ward 15 September 2022

HMRC has issued new guidance on the amount of input tax claimable when an element is attributable to non-business (NB) activities.

If an entity is involved in both business and NB activities, eg; a charity which provides free advice and also has a shop which sells donated goods, it is unable to recover all of the VAT it incurs. VAT attributable to NB activities is not input tax and cannot be reclaimed. Therefore it is necessary to calculate the quantum of VAT attributable to business and NB activities. That VAT which cannot be attributed is called overhead VAT and must be apportioned between business and NB activities. There are many varied ways of doing this as the VAT legislation does not specify any particular method. Therefore it is important to consider all of the available alternatives. Examples of these are; income, expenditure, time, floorspace, transaction count etc (similar to those methods available for partial exemption calculations).

The new guidance is mainly as a result of the Sveda ECJ case.

The definition of business and NB here.

Legislation: The VAT Act 1994 Section 24(5).

Further reading

The following articles consider case law and other relevant business/NB issues:

Lajvér Meliorációs Nonprofit Kft. and Lajvér Csapadékvízrendezési Nonprofit Kft

Healthwatch Hampshire CIC

Pertempts Limited

Northumbria Healthcare

Claiming VAT incurred overseas

By Marcus Ward 20 July 2022

A UK VAT registered business is able to recover VAT it incurs in the EU. However, this is not done on the UK VAT return, but rather by a mechanism known as an “13th Directive” claim (Thirteenth Council Directive 86/560/EEC of 17 November 1986).

Via this procedure a UK business reclaims overseas VAT from the tax authority in the country it was incurred. This is different to the Retail Export Scheme.

Who can claim?

Any UK business which has a certificate of status and meets the following conditions:

The conditions

the UK business has not undertaken any business which would require it to register for VAT in the country in which the claim relates
a business must not have any fixed establishment, seat of economic activity, place of business or other residence (place of belonging) in the country of refund
a VAT invoice is obtained
the VAT was incurred for goods or services which give rise to the right of deduction (see below)

VAT not claimable

The following rules must be applied to a claim, and some claims are specifically refused:

Partial exemption

A business must apply the appropriate recovery rate for purchases using its partial exemption method.

Non-business expenses

Expenditure incurred in another country which relates to non-business activities is not claimable under the refund scheme.

Non-refundable supplies

VAT on the following supplies cannot be claimed

incorrectly invoiced
goods purchased which are subsequently exported

Further, the “usual” rules that apply to a UK VAT claim must be followed.

I have summarised what VAT is not claimable in each EU Member State here.

Minimum claim

Each country has a set minimum claim, but it is mainly around the €50 pa figure.

Time limit

Deadlines to request a refund are not standard and vary country to country. However, they are mainly 30 June or 30 September, and the claims are on a calendar year basis year (it is possible to make quarterly claims which have different deadlines).

How to make a claim

Claimants must send an application to the national tax authority in the country where the VAT was incurred.

Unfortunately, since Brexit, the claims procedure is more complex. There is no longer a single portal and the procedure to request refunds is not standard across the EU. A business needs to research the country specific information on VAT using links provided on the EU Taxation site and a claim for each country must be sent using the procedure set out by that country.

Full rules and procedure to follow can be found in Directive 86/560/EEC

Please note: Some countries require that a claim to be filed by a tax representative authorised by the local tax administration.

Time limits for the country of refund to process an application

The country of refund must notify the applicant of its decision to approve or refuse the application within four months of the date they first received the application.

Payment method

The refund will be paid in the country of refund or, at the applicant’s request, in any Member State. In the latter case, any bank charges for the transfer will be deducted by the country of refund from the amount to be paid to the applicant.

Penalties

All countries take a very serious view of incorrect or false applications. Refunds claimed incorrectly on the basis of incorrect or false information can be recovered and penalties and interest may be imposed, and further refund applications suspended.

Claims refused

If the country of refund refuses an application fully or partly it must notify a claimant of the reasons for refusal.

If this happens an appeal against the decision may be made using the appeals procedure of that country.

Interest on delayed applications

Interest may be payable by the country of refund if payment is made after the deadline.

Claims on UK VAT returns

VAT incurred overseas must not be claimed on a UK VAT return. If it is, it is liable to an assessment, penalties and interest levied in the UK by HMRC.

VAT: Input tax recovery. The Mpala Mufwankolo case

By Marcus Ward 15 November 2021

Latest from the courts

In the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) case of Mr Mufwankolo the dispute was whether the appellant was able to recover VAT charged by the landlord of the property from which he ran his business – a licenced retail outlet on Tottenham High Road.

Background

The landlord had opted to tax the commercial property and charged VAT on the rent. The appellant was a sole proprietor; however, the lease was in the name of Mr Mufwankolo’s wife, and the rent demands showed her name and not that of the sole proprietor. It was contended by the appellant, but not evidenced, that the lease had originally been in both his and his wife’s names, despite his wife being the sole signatory.

The issues

Could the appellant recover input tax?

Did the business receive the supply?
Was there appropriate evidence?

It was clear that the business operated from the relevant property and consequently, in normal circumstances, the rent would be a genuine cost component of the business.

The Decision

The FTT found that there was no entitlement to an input tax claim and the appeal was dismissed. The lease was solely in the wife’s name and the business was the applicant as a sole proprietor. (There was an obvious potential for a partnership and an argument that a partnership was originally intended was advanced. The status of registration was challenged in 2003, but, crucially, not pursued).

It was possible for the property to be sub-let by the wife to the husband, however, this did not affect the VAT treatment as matters stood. Additionally, there was no evidence that the appellant actually paid any of the rent, as this was done by the tenant. There were no VAT invoices addressed to the sole proprietor.

Given the facts, there was no supply to the appellant, so there was no input tax to claim, and the issue of acceptable evidence fell away.

It was a certainty that the appeal could not succeed.

Commentary

There were a number of ways that this VAT cost could have easily been avoided had a little thought been given to the VAT arrangements. An oversight that created an avoidable tax hit.

A helpful guide to input tax considerations here: Care with input tax claims.

Legislation

The VAT Act 1994 Section 3 – Taxable person

The VAT Act 1994 Section 4 – Taxable supply

The VAT Act 1994 Section 24 (1) – Input tax

The VAT Act 1994 Section 24 (6) – Input tax claim evidence

VAT – Building your new home: How and what to claim

By Marcus Ward 17 June 2020

Building your own home is becoming increasingly popular. There are many things to think about, and budgeting is one of the most important.

The recovery of VAT on the project has a huge impact on the budget and care must be taken to ensure that a claim is made properly and within the time limits. You don’t have to be VAT registered to make a claim, this is done via a mechanism known as The DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme. It has specific rules which must be adhered to otherwise the claim will be rejected.

If you buy a new house from a property developer, you will not be charged VAT. This is because the sale of the house to you will be zero-rated. This allows the developer to reclaim the VAT paid on building materials from HMRC. However, if you build a house yourself, you will not be able to benefit from the zero-rating. The DIY Housebuilder’ Scheme puts you in a similar position to a person who buys a zero-rated house built by a property developer.

Who can make a claim?

You can apply for a VAT refund on building materials and services if you are:

building a new home in which you will live
converting a building into a home
building a non-profit communal residence, eg; a hospice
building a property for a charity

Eligibility

New homes

The house must:

be separate and self-contained eg; not an extension
be for you or your family to live or holiday in (not for sale when complete)
not be for business purposes (although you can use one room as a work from home office)
not be prevented from sale independently to another building by planning permission or similar eg; a granny annexe

A claim may also be made for garages built at the same time as the house and to be used with the house.

Contractors working on new residential buildings should zero rate their supplies to you, so you won’t pay any VAT on these.

Conversions

The building being converted must usually be a non-residential building eg; a barn conversion. Also, residential buildings qualify if they haven’t been lived in for at least 10 years.

You may claim a refund for builders’ work on a conversion of non-residential building into home. These supplies will be charged at the reduced rate of 5% for conversion works. If the standard rate of 20% s charged incorrectly, you will not be able to claim the standard rated amount. Care should be taken that the contractor understands the VAT rules for conversions as these can be complex.

Communal and charity buildings

You may get a VAT refund if the building is for one of the following purposes:

non-business – you can’t charge a fee for the use of the building
charitable, eg; a hospice
residential, eg; a children’s home

What can you claim on?

Building materials – You may claim a VAT refund for building materials that are incorporated into the building and can’t be removed without tools or damaging the building.

What doesn’t qualify

You cannot claim for:

building projects outside the UK
materials or services that don’t have any VAT, eg; were zero-rated or exempt
professional or supervisory fees, eg; architects and surveyors
the hire of plant, tools and equipment, eg; generators, scaffolding and skips
building materials that aren’t permanently attached to or part of the building itself
some fitted furniture, electrical and gas appliances, carpets or garden ornaments
supplies for which you do not have a VAT invoice

Examples of items you can, and cannot claim for are listed below.

How to claim

To claim a VAT refund, send form 431NB or 431C to HMRC

Local Compliance National DIY Team
SO987
Newcastle
NE98 1ZZ

What you need to know

You must claim within three months of the building work being completed.

You will usually get the refund in 30 working days of sending the claim.

You must include the following with your claim:

bank details
planning permission
proof the building work is finished eg; a letter from your local authority
a full set of building plans
invoices – including tenders or estimations if the invoice isn’t itemised
bills and any credit notes

VAT invoices must be valid and show the correct rate of VAT or they will not be accepted in the claim.

HMRC usually examine every claim closely and often query them, so it pays to ensure that the claim is as accurate as possible first time. We find a review by us before submission ensures the maximum amount is claimed and delays are avoided.

Payments made after completion of the house cannot be claimed, and only one claim can be made for the whole project, so cashflow may be an issue.

Examples of items that you can claim for

The items listed below are accepted as being ‘ordinarily’ incorporated in a building (or its site). This is not a complete list.

air conditioning
building materials that make up the fabric of the property eg; bricks, cement, tiles, timber, etc
burglar and fire alarms
curtain poles and rails
fireplaces and surrounds
fitted kitchen furniture, sinks, and work surfaces
flooring materials (other than carpets and carpet tiles)
some gas and electrical appliances when wired-in or plumbed-in
heating and ventilation systems including solar panels
light fittings – including chandeliers and outside lights
plumbing materials, including electric showers, ‘in line’ water softeners and sanitary ware
saunas
turf, plants, trees (to the extent that they are detailed on scheme approved by a Planning Permission) and fencing permanently erected around the boundary of the dwelling
TV aerials and satellite dishes

Examples of items that you cannot claim for

This is not a complete list.

Aga/range cookers (unless they are solid fuel, oil-fired or designed to heat space or water)
free-standing and integrated appliances such as: cookers, fridges, freezers, dishwashers, microwaves, washing machines, dryers, coffee machines
audio equipment, built-in speakers, intelligent lighting systems, satellite boxes, Freeview boxes
consumables eg; sandpaper, white spirit
electrical components for garage doors and gates
bedroom furniture (unless they are basic wardrobes) bathroom furniture eg; vanity units and free-standing units
curtains and blinds
carpets and rugs
garden furniture and ornaments and sheds

Please contact us if you require assistance with a DIY Housebuild project.

VAT: Recovery of input tax on fuel costs

By Marcus Ward 22 April 2020

Fuel costs

Road Fuel Scale Charge (RFSC) simplification.

It is common for a staff member to use a car for both business and private purposes (a staff member also covers sole proprietors and partners). Input tax is only recoverable in respect of the business use, so an apportionment is required. This may be done in the following ways.

Apply the RFSC. This is a set figure per month which represents a disallowance for private use and is repaid to HMRC
Keep detailed mileage records and only claim for the business element
If a business pays a mileage allowance for exact business miles travelled it may reclaim input tax on that actual payment. HMRC publish approved Advisory Fuel Rates, which are used to calculate the payments and the recoverable VAT
Do not make a claim at all (if business mileage is minimal or the administration outweighs the cost benefit)

Application

One RFSC must be applied for each car that is used both privately and for business. The fuel scale charges are calculated according to a car’s CO2 emissions and the fixed charge is added to the output figure on the VAT return.

A business will need to check the relevant car’s CO2 emissions figure. This is available for the car’s log book. For dual fuel cars, the lower of the two figures is used.

The calculation

The RFSC allows a business to account for the VAT on fuel in monthly, quarterly or annual returns. When calculating VAT on fuel, if the relevant car has a CO2 emission of 160g, and the business files quarterly returns, the VAT inclusive consideration for a three-month period is £319.00.

The RFSC for the private use of the vehicle will then be calculated as follows: £319.00 x 1/6 (the VAT fraction of the total figure) = £53.16

In this example, the VAT output tax due to HMRC is £53.16 and this is included in Box 1 of the VAT return.

This amount will compensate for any private use of fuel where VAT has already been claimed on the initial purchase of the fuel.

Notes

If a business uses the Flat Rate Scheme no VAT is reclaimable on fuel and no scale charge is applicable.

The RFSC does not apply to commercial vehicles (vans, lorries etc) however, if there is a significant level of private mileage, VAT claims should be adjusted to exclude input tax on this.

HMRC publish updated RFSC valuation tables annually. The latest table is here

Input tax claims may be restricted due to partial exemption or non-business activities.

Help

HMRC have also published a useful ready reckoner tool which assists with the process here

Mileage payments

If a business recovers input VAT based on mileage payments made to employees, it must ensure that employees submit fuel VAT receipts evidencing that they have incurred costs and VAT on fuel. Without such receipts, HMRC may deny the VAT recovery on mileage reimbursements. Clearly, the total VAT incurred on fuel must exceed the business element claimed.

Penalties

Unfortunately, as always with VAT, if errors are made, penalties and interest could apply.