HMRC have issued a BB 5(2024) on Tour Operators’ Margin Scheme (TOMS) for business to business (B2B) wholesale supplies.
Ultimately, the policy allowing businesses to choose whether to apply TOMS to B2B wholesale supplies remains unchanged.
Latest from the courts
In the First-Tier Tribunal (FTT) case of The Squa.re Limited (TSL) the issue was whether unsold inventory or inventory sold at a loss could affect the calculation of the Tour Operators’ Margin Scheme (TOMS).
Background
TSL provided serviced apartments to travellers. The company leased accommodation from the owners of the properties who were frequently, if not exclusively, private individuals who were not registered for VAT.
These leases were often for an extended period, eg; annual leases, such that the appellant is committed under the terms of the lease even where the accommodation cannot then be on supplied or not supplied for a profit.
The Issue
The issue was whether TOMS operated in such a way as to permit a negative calculation resulting in repayment to the appellant. HMRC issued an assessment because, while they accepted that there may be a zero margin on a TOMS supply, they considered that a negative margin was not permitted by the scheme. TSL maintained that a repayment of overdeclared output tax was appropriate if a loss was made (an “overall negative margin”) as TOMS does not exclude the possibility of a negative margin.
The dispute between the parties was a technical one only and concerned the interpretation of the statutory provisions implementing TOMS into UK law.
Legal
The domestic implementation of the TOMS is authorised by The Value Added Tax Act 1994, Section 53 and found in Value Added Tax (Tour Operators’) Order 1987 (SI1987/1806). Guidance is provided via Notice 709/5 and Sections 8 to 13 have the force of law.
Decision
The Tribunal determined that it was clear from the legislation that the taxable amount is concerned with the supply made, and not the VAT incurred on the various cost components. Under normal VAT accounting the output tax charged on supplies is calculated by reference to the consideration received by the supplier from the customer. There can realistically be no concept of negative consideration.
The FTT considered that there is no basis inherent within TOMS which would permit a calculation of a negative sum. There had been a supply (of a designated travel service) for a consideration, and it is the taxable amount of that supply which was to be determined. A negative taxable amount is a “conceptual impossibility”. A negative margin arises as a consequence of a lack of profitability, but VAT is a transaction tax and not a tax on profit.
When sold at a loss where the total calculation resulted in a negative margin the annual sum due by way of output tax would be nil (not a repayment).
Where the accommodation is not sold at all, the FTT noted that this cost represented a cost of doing business but, on the basis that there has been no onward supply, there is no supply which meets the definition of a designated travel service. The relevant accommodation is not for the direct benefit of any traveller so there is no supply and TOMS is irrelevant.
Whilst the FTT considered that were it the case that identified costs incurred in buying in goods and services which are not then the subject of an onward supply should be excluded from TOMS calculations, costs associated with the block booking of accommodation of the type incurred by TSL were to be included. Where such costs exceed the value obtained by onward supply, the negative margin forms part of the annual calculation. However, where the global calculation results in a negative margin the tax due for the year under TOMS is nil and there was no basis for a repayment to TSL.
There was no basis on which to permit an overall TOMS negative margin and the appeal was dismissed.
Commentary
Another demonstration of the complexities of TOMS and the potential pitfalls.
It may be useful to note that input tax claims are not permitted in TOMS calculations, however, any VAT incurred on any bought in, but unsold, services would not be excluded from recovery as there is no TOMS supply. The input tax on unsold inventory was a general cost of doing business and, as such, recoverable in the normal way. Consequently, there may be circumstances for businesses using TOMS where input tax incurred on unsold elements may be claimed outside of TOMS
I am often asked if there is a VAT beginner’s guide, I find HMRC guidance generally unhelpful for someone without a tax background, so, here is all the basic information you may need in one place.
What is VAT?
Value Added Tax (VAT) is a tax charged on most business transactions made in the UK. It is charged on goods and services and is an ad valorem tax, which means it is proportionate to the value of the supply made.
All goods and services that are VAT rated (at any rate including zero) are called “taxable supplies”. VAT must be charged on taxable supplies from the date a business first needs to be registered. The value of these supplies is called the “taxable turnover”.
Exempt items
VAT does not apply to certain services because the law says these are exempt from VAT. These include some; financial services, property transactions, insurance education and healthcare. Supplies that are exempt from VAT do not form part of the taxable turnover.
The VAT rates
There are currently three rates of VAT in the UK:
VAT registration
A business is required to register for, and charge VAT, if:
Registration limit
The current VAT registration threshold is £85,000. If at the end of any month the value of taxable supplies made in the past twelve months is more than this figure a business MUST VAT register. A business can opt to register for VAT if its taxable turnover is less than this. Please note that taxable turnover is the amount of income received by a business and not just profit. If a business does not register at the correct time it will be fined.
Additionally, if, at any time there are reasonable grounds to expect that the value of the taxable supplies will be more than the threshold in the next thirty days alone a business must register immediately.
What are the exceptions?
VAT is not chargeable on:
What if a business only makes exempt or zero-rated supplies?
Exempt
If a business only makes exempt supplies, it cannot be registered for VAT. If a business is registered for VAT and makes some exempt supplies, it may not be able to reclaim all of its input tax.
Zero rated
If a business only supplies goods or services which are zero-rated, it does not have to register for VAT, but, it may do so if it chooses.
What is input tax and output tax?
Input tax is the VAT a business pays to its suppliers for goods and services. It is VAT on goods or services coming into a business. In most cases, input tax is the VAT that registered businesses can reclaim (offset against output tax).
Output tax is the term used to describe the VAT charged on a business’ sales of goods or services. Output tax is the VAT a business collects from its customers on each sale it makes.
A full guide to VAT jargon here
Is there anything that will make VAT simpler for a small business?
There are a number of simplified arrangements to make VAT accounting easier for small businesses. These are:
Details may be found here and here and here.
VAT calculation
Records
A business must keep complete, up-to-date records that enable it to calculate the correct amount of VAT to declare on its returns. VAT records must be kept for at least six years, because a business will need to show them to HMRC when asked.
It is acceptable for ordinary business records to be the basis for VAT accounts. A business will need records of sales and purchases (and any adjustments such as credit notes) including details of how much VAT the business charged or paid. If trading internationally, records of imports and exports/dispatches and acquisitions with all overseas territories, including the EU must be recorded. VAT records must show details of any supplies a business has given away or taken for personal use.
VAT records must also include all invoices you have received and issued. Invoice requirements here
Records will also need to include a VAT account, showing how total input tax and output tax has been calculated to include in your VAT returns.
It is vital to ensure that the VAT records are accurate. Failure to do so can lead to significant tax penalties
MTD
For certain business, the new MTD rules apply and certain software must be used. Details here
Time of supply (tax point)
It is important to establish the time VAT is due. Full details here
VAT returns
A VAT registered business must submit returns on a regular basis (usually quarterly or monthly). A VAT return summarises a business’ sales and purchases and the VAT relating to them. All the information a business requires must be in its VAT records, specifically a VAT account.
Return requirements include:
Online VAT returns are due one month and seven days after the end of the VAT period. Payment of any VAT owed is due at the same time, although HMRC will collect direct debit payments three days later.