Tag Archives: vat-free

VAT: Transactions involving Bitcoin

By   21 July 2025
0
I have written about this subject a number of times about transactions involving cryptocurrencies, and considering the increased use of them, it seems timely to provide an update on the VAT treatment of certain business activities which use Bitcoins as a value for exchange, or payment for goods or services.

What is cryptocurrency?

Cryptocurrency is a line of computer code that holds monetary value. Cryptocurrency is also known as digital currency and it is a form of money that is created by mathematical computations. In order for a Bitcoin transaction to take place, a verification process is needed, this is provided by millions of computer users called miners and the monitoring is called mining. Transactions are recorded in the blockchain which is public and contains records of each and every transaction that takes place. Cryptocurrency is not tangible, although they may be exchanged for traditional cash. It is a decentralised digital currency without a central bank or single administrator (which initially made it attractive) and can be sent from user to user on the peer-to-peer network without the need for intermediaries.

What is Bitcoin?

Bitcoin was the first popular cryptocurrency and it first appeared in 2009. The advantage of bitcoin is that it can be stored offline on the owner’s local hardware (a process called cold storage) which protects the currency from being taken by others. If a person loses access to the hardware that contains the bitcoins, the currency is lost forever, and it is estimated that as much as 23% of bitcoin has been mislaid by miners and/or investors.

Exchange between currencies and bitcoin

The VAT treatment of transactions exchanging traditional currencies for Bitcoin, or Bitcoin for currencies carried out for consideration (added by the supplier) are exempt services in a similar way to any other currency transactions via The VAT Act 1994, Schedule 9, group 5, item 1.

Paying for goods or services using Bitcoin

Similar to any other payment method, simply using Bitcoin to obtain goods or services is outside the scope of VAT and no VAT is due on the value the Bitcoin represents. That is to say that the authorities do not consider that such a transaction is a barter.

Provision of goods or services in return for Bitcoin payment

The provision of goods or services paid for in Bitcoin are treated in a similar way as any supplied for consideration consisting of

  • Traditional currencies, or
  • Non-monetary consideration

and the value is; anything received by the supplier in consideration of that supply.

Should the consideration be in Bitcoin, there two alternatives for the conversion of foreign currencies into a main currency (although these were drafted before the introduction of Bitcoin and originally relate simply to foreign currencies)

  • the latest exchange rate recorded on the most representative exchange market, or
  • the latest exchange rate published by the European Central Bank

However, as above, because Bitcoin is not administered by any bank, this may make valuation difficult. The VAT Committee of the European Commission (EC) has indicated that a potential resolution is to use Open Market Rate (OMR*) as the exchange of the virtual currency. This would be the responsibility of the supplier. This is likely to be commercially available information from the websites of the likes of; coindesk, Cryptocompare or Cointelegraph for eg.

All of the above seems logical, although confirmation provided by the VAT Committee is welcome.

* OMR is the amount for which an asset is transferred between a willing buyer and a willing seller in an arm’s-length transaction after proper marketing wherein the parties had each acted knowledgeably, prudently, and without compulsion.

VAT Notice 708: Buildings and construction updated

By   1 July 2025
0

This Notice explains how to establish the appropriate VAT rate on building work and materials for contractors, sub-contractors and developers.

The construction of a new building and work to an existing building is normally standard rated. However, there are exceptions to this, inter alia:

  • construction of new qualifying dwellings and communal residential buildings, and certain new buildings used by charities ― zero-rated
  • conversion for a housing association of a non-residential building into a qualifying dwelling or communal residential building ― zero-rated
  • alterations to suit the condition of people with disabilities ― zero-rated
  • first time gas and electricity connections ― zero-rated
  • conversion of a non-residential building into a qualifying dwelling or communal residential building ― reduced rate of VAT 5%
  • renovation or alteration of empty residential premises ― reduced rate of VAT 5%
  • installation of energy saving materials, grant funded heating system measures and qualifying security goods ― reduced rate of VAT 5%
  • installation of mobility aids for the elderly for use in domestic accommodation ― reduced rate of VAT 5%

(These are just some examples; other works may also qualify for zero or reduced rating)

Amendments

Paragraph 7 (re: the conversion of premises to a different residential use) on reduced rated work has been amended at para 7.6 as there was uncertainty over the previous drafting.

Paragraph 8.4 has been revised to more accurately reflect the rules on the installation of building materials which are reduce rated.

A VAT Did you know?

By   30 June 2025
0

Lugworms and maggots are standard rated, unless they are also suitable for human consumption, in which case they may be zero-rated – Yum.

VAT: Updated Notice – Local authorities and similar bodies

By   10 June 2025
0

Notice 749 has been updated. This is guidance for Local authorities, government departments, non-departmental public bodies, NHS bodies, local government bodies, the police and the fire and rescue services.

It sets out:

  • which activities of local authorities and similar bodies are business or non-business for VAT purposes
  • the VAT registration requirements for local authorities
  • when local authorities and certain similar bodies can reclaim VAT incurred on costs that relate to their non-business activities

The changes amend:

  • Section ‘7.2 Insignificant proportion’ has been updated to remove a reference to VAT attributed and apportioned to exempt supplies.
  • Section ‘7.5 What to do if you want to opt for a special section 33 VAT recovery method to recover the VAT incurred’ the deadline for using a special section 33 recovery method has been changed from 31 October to 30 September following the end of the financial year.

Section 33 bodies

“Section 33 bodies” per The VAT Act 1994, section 33)

These entities have special VAT treatment which is effectively the opposite of normal VAT rules. To avoid a cost to the taxpayer, these entities are permitted to specifically recover input tax that relates to non-business activities. Nobody said that VAT was straightforward and in these cases, the VAT rules are inverted!

We act for many Local Authorities and Academies. Please contact us should you, or your clients, have any queries on this matter.

VAT: Are poppadoms crisps? The Walkers Snack Foods case

By   4 June 2025
0

Latest from the courts  

In the Walkers Snack Foods Ltd Upper Tribunal (UT) case the issue was whether Sensations Poppadoms are similar to potato crisps and consequently excluded from the zero rating for food.

The First-Tier Tribunal (FTT) found that the product was similar to crisps and that it was to be treated as being excepted items from zero-rating and was therefore standard rated.

Background

The salient matter was whether the poppadoms were “made from the potato, or from potato flour, or from potato starch” and were “similar” to potato crisps via The VAT Act 1994, Schedule 8, Group 1, item 1, excepted item 5.

Value Added Tax – excepted item 5 to item 1, Group 1, Part II, Schedule 8 Value Added Tax Act 1994 – whether First-tier Tribunal erred in law in finding Sensations Poppadoms were “made from the potato, or from potato flour, or from potato starch” and were “similar” to potato crisps

This sets out that the following is excepted from the zero rate for “Food of a kind used for human consumption”.

“5. Any of the following when packaged for human consumption without further preparation, namely, potato crisps, potato sticks, potato puffs, and similar products made from the potato, or from potato flour, or from potato starch, and savoury food products obtained by the swelling of cereals or cereal products; and salted or roasted nuts other than nuts in shell.”

Contentions

The appellant argued that the poppadoms should be zero-rated for VAT purposes because they fall within Item 1 of Group 1 as they are food, and that they are not included in the list of exceptions.

 HMRC contended that that the product fell within excepted item 5 of Group 1, because they are products similar to potato crisps…

Decision 

  • The UT agreed with the FTT that the words “made from the potato” can extend to products made from potato granules and was neither untenable nor a plain misapplication of the law to the facts. 
  • The UT recalled that the FTT had concluded that Sensations Poppadoms contained “more than enough potato content” for it to be reasonable to conclude that they were “made from the potato… or from potato starch”. Sensations Poppadoms have a combined potato content (potato granules and potato starch) of 39%-40%, so the potato content is significant. The question for the UT was whether the FTT reached a conclusion which no reasonable tribunal properly construing the statute could have reached. The UT answered “no”.
  • The UT noted that the FTT determined that Sensations Poppadoms were similar to potato crisps based on a multifactorial assessment of various factors, including; packaging, appearance, texture and taste. The FTT noted that while the manufacturing processes differ, the statute allows for similarity among products made from potato starch and flour. The FTT found that the potato content in Sensations Poppadoms contributed to a neutral flavour, which did not significantly distinguish them from potato crisps. Broadly, the UT agreed with this determination.

Consequently, for the above reasons the UT dismissed the appeal and the product is subject to the standard rate.

Commentary

Yet another case on the liability of ‘snack foods’. So now we know that: Doritos, Monster Munch, Wotsits and Poppadums are standard rated, however Pringles, Skips and Twiglets are VAT free. This demonstrates the complexity of classifying food and these decisions throw up more complications for producers as this market develops quickly as the public’s taste moves on.

VAT: New guidance on exception from registration

By   2 June 2025
0

HMRC has published new guidance which sets out how to apply for VAT registration exception if a business has temporarily exceeded the VAT registration threshold of £90,000 in any 12-month period (a rolling calculation).

What is registration exception?

If a business has a one-off increase in income it can apply for a registration exception. If its taxable turnover goes over the threshold temporarily it can write to HMRC with evidence showing why the taxable turnover will not exceed the deregistration threshold (currently £88,000 in the next 12 months). HMRC will consider an exception and write confirming if a business will receive one. If not, HMRC will compulsorily register the business for VAT. A business will need to formally apply to HMRC to make this exception official.

The guidance explains:

  • when to apply
  • how to apply
  • what happens after the application

Forms

A business will need to complete forms VAT1 and VAT5EXC in order to apply for registration exception. HMRC will write to the applicant within 40 working days of receipt with a decision.

If HMRC approves the application for exception

HMRC will not register the business for VAT. However, this is a ‘one-off’ and does not mean that the business will never have to register.

The value of taxable supplies must be checked every month, to establish whether they have exceeded the registration threshold. If they have, the business must:

  • register for VAT
  • apply for exception again

If HMRC refuses the application for exception

The response letter will explain why, and the information provided on the form VAT 1 will be used to VAT register the business. The applicant will need to account for VAT from the date it was liable.

A VAT Did you know?

By   20 May 2025
0

The sale of ostriches is zero rated, but kangaroos are standard rated. Both are sold as food.

VAT: Whether an online tool an ‘examination service’? The Generic Maths case.

By   12 May 2025
0

Latest from the courts.

In the Generic Maths Limited First Tier Tribunal case the issue was whether the appellant’s product; ‘ConquerMaths’ amounted to examination services so to be exempt via The VATA 1994, Schedule 9, Group 6, Item 3.

Background

Generic Maths provided an online tool which was intended to be of benefit to students or their parents/teachers. The following facts concerning ConquerMaths were found:

  • it does not lead to any qualifications
  • users can drop in and out of the offering (unlike the way they might have to proceed if following a course leading to a qualification)
  • it includes many hundreds of available diagnostic tests that test students’ knowledge of the principles that will be taught on the various subjects
  • several short tutoring videos are included, although the number of videos is small in comparison to the number of diagnostic tests
  • the average user spends 75 minutes on diagnostic tests compared to five minutes on videos
  • the appellant’s witnesses described the product as diagnostic assessments, formative assessments, and summative assessments
  • in addition to the diagnostic tests, the product includes worksheets in an exam format. Pupils are encouraged to complete these offline and then feed the results into the system

The issue

Simply put; was the product predominantly a tool that provides assessments enabling those using the product to determine what level of maths ability the student has reached and identify any gaps in knowledge and therefore an exempt supply since it falls into the category “examination services”? Or, as HMRC contended, was it an online mathematical tutorial tool which was standard rated as it was a composite supply the predominant element of which was education and that the supply was not one of examination services? (There was no argument that these were exempt educational services).

The tests

The FTT considered that the correct test for determining the nature of the appellant’s supplies was an objective test, based on how they would be characterised by the typical consumer. On that basis, ConquerMaths was a teaching product designed to improve maths understanding, not an examination service.

Additionally, if the correct test was rather a functional test, the result would be the similar.

Decision

The Tribunal did not consider that the product was a supply of examination services within Item 3. It found that the assessment had been made using best judgment by HMRC and accordingly that the appeal should be dismissed.

Commentary

This is probably the correct decision, although the examination and education exemptions are open to interpretation. Care should be taken by taxpayers that the exemption is correctly applied. Although the definition of examination services is wider than formal public examinations, it was not wide enough to encompass ConquerMaths.

VAT Planning: design and build

By   6 May 2025
0

Planning

The construction of a new house, and the materials used by the contractor to build it, are zero-rated. However, architect and other building professional fees, eg; surveyors, supervisors, engineers, project or construction management and consultants, are always standard rated; even in respect of a new build.

This will represent an absolute VAT cost to:

  • individuals
  • entities which will rent the house(s) after completion
  • housing associations (in some circumstances)
  • certain entities which are not in business
  • any entity which will use the building(s) for other exempt purposes
  • entities which do not sell the house(s) – so onward zero-rating is not possible
  • any entity which cannot recover all of its input tax for various reasons

Aims

If it is not possible to structure matters so that these fees can be recovered (there are a number ways to do this, but not all will be available to all parties) then advisers need to consider ways to remove the VAT charge – this may also be preferable for cashflow purposes even if full input tax recovery is possible.

VAT Planning

Design and build – the steps

  • the housebuilder creates a separately VAT registered design and build company (newco)
  • newco purchases the professional services and construction services and incurs the VAT on these (the construction element is zero-rated)
  • these supplies are incorporated into a single onward supply of zero-rated design and build services to the housebuilder (a bundle) – the professional services are a cost component of the construction
  • zero rating applies to the supply to the housebuilder as the predominant supply of the bundle is the construction of new dwellings
  • newco recovers the input tax incurred on professional fees etc, as it relates to an onward taxable supply
  • newco is in a repayment position and HMRC refunds the VAT incurred on the costs – often after a pre-cred query

It is also possible to use an independent design and build company, or engage a contractor to carry out both the design and construction elements of the project with a similar result.

Considerations

It is important to implement the planning correctly. This means that appropriate contracts must be in place, the operation is carried out on sound business principles (actual supplies are made and it is not simply the moving of money).

Arrangements

In order to evidence the proper commerciality of the structure, it is important to bear in mind that:

  • appropriate contracts are in place
  • proper invoicing is required
  • the arrangements are at arm’s length
  • a profit for newco would emphasise the commercial aspect
  • all parties’ accounts reflect the transactions
  • newco combines all of its costs (including overheads/admin etc) and supplies them to the housebuilder as part of a single package of zero-rated design and build services
  • newco acts as principal and not agent (that the professional services are not disbursements)
  • the newco and the housebuilder are not in the same VAT group
  • care should be taken if loans are required (they may compromise arm’s length and genuine commercial contentions)

HMRC’s view

In HMRC’s Internal Guidance Manual VCONST02720 it states that:

“Zero-rating the construction of buildings: services excluded from zero rating: design and build

Architectural or design services supplied as part of a design and build contract can be treated as part of the zero-rated supply of construction services.

A typical design and build contract will require the contractor to complete the design for the works and complete the construction of the works.

In such circumstances HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) sees the design element as a cost component of the construction and not as a separate supply of architectural services which would be liable to VAT at the standard rate”.

Consequently, this planning is recognised and accepted by HMRC, however, it is important that it is applied effectively so it is difficult for HMRC to challenge.

A VAT Did you know?

By   28 April 2025
0

Grass seed is zero-rated, but turf is standard rated.