HMRC has issued two new documents which provide practical guidance for users of the One Stop Shop (OSS).
They cover how to pay the VAT due on an OSS return and how to use the service to submit an OSS VAT return if a business is registered for the OSS Union Scheme. A link has been added to allow a business to submit a OSS return directly.
HMRC have updated VAT Notice 701/38 Seeds and plants that can be zero-rated. This Notice explains how to zero rate supplies of of seeds and plants which are used to grow food for human consumption. The supply of most basic foodstuffs for human or animal consumption is zero-rated. Plants and seeds used for the production of foodstuffs are also zero-rated depending on how they are held out for sale. The Notice explains when the following items can be zero-rated:
The main amendments have been made to paragraph 3.5 – Trees and fruit bearing shrubs.
Any businesses supplying such goods (garden centres, nurseries etc) should ensure that the available zero rating is applied as widely as possible within these rules.
Latest from the courts
In the Upper Tribunal (UT) case of Babylon Farm Ltd (the farm) the issue was whether the appellant was in business and consequently was able to recover certain input tax.
Background
Yet another case on whether there was any business activity in a company. Please see here, here, here and here for previous cases on this issue. The farm sold hay which it cut from another person’s fields to a connected party. The value of the one-off annual sale was £440 pa. The appellant also contended that it was also undertaking preparatory acts for the new business activities and that it would be able to levy management charges. Another new business activity was the creation of an investment and insurance product.
The farm built a new barn on which it claimed input tax of £19,760.
HMRC considered that no business was being carried on and decided to deregister the farm thus refusing to pay the input tax claim. The farm challenged this decision and contended that taxable supplies were being made, and there was also an intention to make taxable supplies in the future.
Legislation
Paragraph 9 of Schedule 1 of the VAT Act 1994 requires HMRC to be satisfied that a person is either making taxable supplies or is carrying on a business and intends to make such supplies in the course or furtherance of a business in order to be registered for VAT. There are a number of tests set out in case law (mainly The Lord Fisher case) to establish whether a person is in business:
Decision
The appeal was dismissed. The farm was not in business and could not recover input tax on the costs of the new barn.
The judge stated that he could see no legal basis for the farm to be in business. The hay that the farm sold was taken from the customer’s own land and therefore belonged to him already. It was also noted that no invoices were raised, no payment for the hay had been made for a number of years and the single customer was a director of Babylon Farm Limited so the farm was not operating in an open market. The sale of hay had not been conducted on a basis that followed sound and recognised business principles or on a basis that was predominantly concerned with the making of taxable supplies for consideration. As a consequence, the farm was not operating as a business during the relevant period.
On the intention point; neither of the intended activities had yet resulted in any chargeable services being provided and both were to be carried on through companies that had been formed for these purposes (not the farm). Both businesses remained at a formative stage and neither company has generated any revenue. This was insufficient to retain the VAT registration.
Commentary
The decision was hardly a surprise and one wonders how it reached the UT. HMRC were always going to challenge an input tax claim of that quantum with no output tax (and such a low value of sales which may not have been made in any event).
HMRC has published details of the tax gap for 2019/20. This is the gap between the expected tax that should be paid to HMRC and what is actually paid. The headline was that the tax gap was 5.3%. which represents an estimated £35 billion.
Total tax liabilities for the year were £674 billion.
What is the tax gap?
The tax gap is the difference between the amount of tax that should, in theory, be paid to HMRC, and what is actually paid.
Why is it measured?
The tax gap provides tool for understanding the relative size and nature of non-compliance. This understanding can be applied in many different ways:
Why is there a tax gap?
The tax gap arises for a number of reasons. Some taxpayers make simple errors in calculating the tax that they owe, despite their best efforts, while others don’t take enough care when they submit their returns. Legal interpretation, evasion, avoidance and criminal attacks on the tax system also result in a tax gap.
Analysis
Around £3.7 billion of the gap is estimated to be due to error and £3 billion due to the hidden economy.
The tax gap for wealthy individuals fell from £1.6 billion in 2018/19 to £1.5 billion in 2019/20
£15.1 billion of the gap is attributed to small businesses and £6.1 billion is attributed to large businesses, with £5 billion attributed to medium-sized firms.
Taxpayers paid more than £633.4 billion in tax during 2019/20, an increase of more than £100 billion since 2015/16, when the total revenue paid was £532.5 billion.
The tax gap for Income Tax, National Insurance contributions and Capital Gains Tax is 3.5% in 2019 to 2020 at £12.6 billion which represents the largest share of the total tax gap by type of tax.
VAT
The VAT gap was estimated to be £12.3 billion in tax year 2019 to 2020. This equates to 8.4% of net VAT total theoretical liability.
The VAT gap has increased from 7.0% in tax year 2018 to 2019 to 8.4% in 2019 to 2020. Growth in VAT receipts (1.8%) was slower than the growth in the net VAT total theoretical liability (3.3%).
Behaviour
HMRC estimate that the causes of the tax gap are:
Taxpayers
Tax gap by taxpayer groups:
The impact on the tax gap from the coronavirus lockdowns and economic downturn is likely to be first seen in the 2020/21 figures, which will be released next year. It will also be interesting to see how the fallout from Brexit is covered (if at all).
HMRC has published updated guidance VAT Notice 723A which sets out how a business established outside the UK can claim a refund of VAT incurred here, and how to reclaim VAT incurred in the EU VAT if a business is established in the UK.
More details of how to make post-Brexit VAT claims here.
HM Treasury has announced that government spending plans will be set out at the Spending Review on 27 October 2021 alongside an Autumn Budget.
The Spending Review will set out the plan for how public spending will be carried out over the next three years.
Crisps: VAT is due on potato snacks, but maize and corn-based snacks are VAT free. (But Pringles are standard rated even though they contain corn, wheat and non-potato flours and the potato content is less than 50%).
Latest from the courts
The First-Tier tribunal (FTT) considered the case of CMJ (Aberdeen) Limited (CMJ) and whether the supply of building services in respect of the construction of a dwelling were correctly zero rated by the appellant. HMRC deemed that the construction services were standard rated on the basis that the works were not carried out in accordance with the terms of the relevant statutory planning consent.
Background
HMRC’s view was that, although planning consent was in place at the time the construction services were supplied by the appellant, that planning consent permitted only the alteration or enlargement of a dwelling and did not allow for the construction of a dwelling. HMRC accept that the property was constructed as a new building, but that this was not permitted by the planning consent and so the construction was not carried out in accordance with it.
CMJ contended that statutory planning consent had been obtained for the construction via a combination of the planning consent and a construction building warrant which it had obtained from the relevant authority, and which allowed for the construction of a new building.
Legislation
The zero rating for the construction of new dwellings is contained in The VAT Act 1994, Schedule 8, Group 5, item 2
“The supply in the course of the construction of
(a) a building designed as a dwelling…”
Note 2 to Group 5 of Schedule 8 to the VAT Act include the following:
“(2) A building is designed as a dwelling or a number of dwellings where in relation to each dwelling the following conditions are satisfied…
…(d) statutory planning consent has been granted in respect of that dwelling and its construction or conversion has been carried out in accordance with that consent.
Decision
The appeal was dismissed. It was judged that the building warrant did not comprise statutory planning consent for the purposes of note 2 (d) because:
It was not possible to carry out works of construction in accordance with a valid statutory consent, since no such consent had been given for construction at the time that the building works were carried out.
Commentary
The legislation covering building work is complex and there are many traps for the unwary. Even the seemingly straightforward matter of whether a new dwelling is constructed can produce difficulties, as in this case. We always counsel that proper VAT advice is sought in such circumstances.
A reminder that a new VAT rate of 12.5% comes into force on 1 October 2021.
This is the first time this rate has been used and affected businesses should ensure that they are prepared.
The government announced on 8 July 2020 that it intended to legislate to apply a temporary 5% reduced rate of VAT to certain supplies relating to certain hospitality, supplies.
The reduced rate was initially introduced to last for a temporary period between 15 July 2020 and 12 January 2021. This period was subsequently extended to 31 March 2021.
The government then announced at Budget 2021 that the temporary reduced rate will be extended for a further six-month period at 5% until 30 September 2021.
A new reduced rate of 12.5% will then be introduced which will end on 31 March 2022. The scope of the relief will remain unchanged.
From 1 April 2022 the usual 20% standard rate will apply, unless there are further government concessions.
The 12.5% applies to
The VAT Fractions
This is used to calculate the VAT element of a VAT inclusive figure.
5% = 1/21
12.5% = 1/9
20% = 1/6
Deposits
If a deposit is received, output tax will be calculated on the VAT rate in place at the time the deposit is received.
Other Issues
If a business supplies hospitality services and goods, but also makes sales not covered by the new rate, eg; alcohol, it must be able to identify the values at the different rates.
Does your accounting package have a defined 12.5% tax rate? It may be necessary to add this new rate to your software package.
Further to my article on VAT: Land and property simplification and HMRC’s call for evidence the ICAEW has reiterated its call for all VAT land and property exemptions to be abolished and recommends the removal of all VAT options.
ICAEW also concludes that following the UK’s departure from the EU the government is in the best position since the introduction of VAT to thoroughly review the structure of the tax.
ICAEW also suggests that all land and property transactions should subject to VAT at either the standard rate or reduced rate, other than those relating to domestic property which should remain zero rated. This approach would remove many of the complexities of the current regime, it concludes.
Commentary
This is one area of the tax that is crying out for simplification and the case put forward by ICAEW has its merits. In my view, the Government should go further and review many complexities of the tax. As one example, the rules in respect of the sale of food products is ridiculously complex and produces odd and unexpected outcomes. Also, other exemptions would benefit from reconsideration, particularly financial services and insurance, but I suspect that the current government has a lot on its plate, much of it of its own making.