Size matters Part III – Bay plants are VAT free – as long as they are no bigger than 50cm and they have not been clipped or shaped.
Tag Archives: penalties
VAT: Electronic Sales Suppression (ESS)
HMRC has published new guidance on ESS and information on how to make a disclosure.
What is ESS?
ESS is also known as till fraud or till manipulation. It is where a business manipulates their till systems to hide or reduce the true value or number of sales. This is carried out through the use of ESS tools such as misusing built in till functions or installing software specifically designed to suppress sales. HMRC call this sales suppression and it is done either at, or after, the point of sale (POS). The records then appear to be correct and complete.
Businesses do this to reduce their turnover so that they pay less tax. They also do this to try to appear compliant.
Misusing a till system reduces the recorded turnover of the business and the amount of VAT payable, whilst providing what appears to be an accurate and complete record.
ESS is tax fraud. You are involved with ESS if you have made, supplied, promoted, possess or have access to an ESS tool.
You are also involved in ESS if:
- you own an ESS tool
- have access to an ESS tool
- have tried to access an ESS tool
What is an ESS tool?
An ESS tool is a piece of software, computer code script or hardware. It allows a business to hide or reduce the value of individual transactions on its electronic sales records. This includes using and/or configuring a till, or point of sale system, in a way that suppresses sales.
You do not have to have used an ESS tool to suppress sales or pay less VAT for HMRC to charge a penalty for being involved in ESS, it is fraud regardless.
HMRC powers
Finance Act 2022, Schedule 14 allows HMRC to issue an information notice for ESS. This means HMRC can ask for certain information that only applies to ESS. It allows the issue of a Notice to a ‘relevant person’ for a ‘relevant purpose’.
Who is a ‘relevant person’
A ‘relevant person’ is any person who HMRC think it might be able to charge a penalty for being involved in ESS.
What is a ‘relevant purpose’
A ‘relevant purpose’ is the reason that HMRC is asking for information about ESS and ESS Tools. The law allows HMRC to do this in three types of situations which are to help it:
- decide whether a relevant person has made, supplied, promoted, or possesses an ESS tool — HMRC would be able to charge this person a penalty
- understand how an ESS tool works
- identify any other person who has made, supplied, promoted, or possesses the ESS tool
Disclosure
HMRC is offering an opportunity for those involved in ESS to make a disclosure. Early voluntary disclosure could lead to a reduction in financial penalties. Use the ‘Make a disclosure about misusing your till system’ form to tell HMRC that you have been using your till system to reduce your tax bill.
Further reading and more detailed information on penalties here.
Why are Certificates Of Origin important? An overview
What is a Certificate of Origin (CO)?
A CO is a formal, official document which evidences in which country a good or commodity was manufactured. The certificate of origin contains information regarding the product, its destination, and the country of export.
A CO is required for most treaty agreements for cross-border trade and have become more important since Brexit (no more single market alas).
Why is a CO important?
The CO is an important document because it determines whether certain goods are eligible for import, or whether goods are subject to duties.
CO – General
Customs officials expect the CO to be a separate document from other commercial documents such as invoices or packing lists. Officials may also expect it to be signed by the exporter, the signature notarised, and the document subsequently signed and stamped by a Chamber of Commerce. Additionally, the destination Customs authority may request proof of review from a specific Chamber of Commerce.
Some countries accept electronically issued COs which have been electronically signed by a Chamber of Commerce.
Types of CO
A CO can be either in paper or digital format and must be approved by the requisite Customs Authority.
There is no standard CO document for global trade, but a CO prepared by the exporter, has at least the basic details about the product being shipped.
Non-Preferential Cos
Non-preferential COs, also known as “ordinary COs” indicate that the goods do not qualify for reduced tariffs or tariff-free treatment under trade arrangements between countries. If an exporting country does not have in place a treaty or trade agreement with the importing country, an ordinary CO will be needed.
Preferential COs
This is for shipments between countries with a trade agreement or reduced tariffs and proves the goods qualify for reduced import duties.
Legalised CO
Some countries require additional information to demonstrate the authenticity of the information in the CO. A Legalised CO is an ordinary CO that has been further authenticated. The legalisation process usually involves the CO being validated by various appropriate authorities to give more evidence to its authenticity.
Certified CO
A Certified CO is similar to a n ordinary CO. However, it has been certified by a Chamber of Commerce, government agency or other relevant authority to confirm its authenticity.
Certification involves an in-depth review of all of the information declared on the CO, as well as a thorough side-by-side comparison with the requirements of the trade agreement and regulations of the country of import to ensure full compliance.
EUR1
A EUR1 certificate is used in trade between the UK and partner countries. It is used to confirm that goods originate in the EU or a partner country so that the importer can benefit from a reduced rate of import duty.
EUR1 certificates are issued by Chambers of Commerce or Customs offices.
Contents of a CO
A CO will typically contain the following information:
- name and contact information of the manufacturer of the goods
- country of origin
- contact information of the exporting agent
- contact information of the receiver/importing agent
- description of the goods, including the appropriate product codes
- quantity, size, and weight of goods
- A waybill or bill of lading number
- means of transport and route information
- commercial invoice of payment
* A waybill is a document issued by a carrier giving details and instructions relating to the shipment of a consignment of cargo. It shows the names of the consignor and consignee, the point of origin of the consignment, its destination, and route.
How do I find out if I need a CO?
A business will need to check with its local Chamber of Commerce.
VAT: Payments on account – update
HMRC have updated its payments on account (POA) guidance.
What are POA?
These are advance payments towards a business’s VAT bill. They are mandatory.
HMRC will notify a taxpayer to make POA if a business renders VAT returns quarterly, and it owes more than £2.3 million in any period of 12 months or less.
Under the POA arrangement, businesses make interim payments at the end of months two and three for each return quarter. The interim payment is intended to cover part of the overall VAT liability for the that quarter. The balancing payment for the return’s VAT liability will be settled when the business submits its VAT return payment. Quarterly VAT returns are filed online as normal.
POA calculation
HMRC will calculate POA based on a business’s annual VAT liability in the period that it goes over the threshold. The annual VAT liability in that period will be divided by 24 to arrive at an instalment amount.
A taxable person who has been in business for less than 12 months will have POA calculated by HMRC on a pro rata basis.
POA start date and annual cycle
The payments on account cycle starts in the first quarter after a business exceeds the £2.3 million threshold.
The payments will remain the same until the start of the next annual cycle.
The annual cycle begins in April, May or June depending on which VAT return ‘stagger’ a business is on. HMRC bases the amount of payments during the annual cycle on the liability in the period known as the ‘reference year’.
POA due dates
The due dates for POA are the last working day of the second and third months of every VAT quarter no matter what the period end date is. The seven-day extension for paying electronically does not apply to POA.
POA that are not paid on time will be subject to late payment interest.
Due dates for quarterly balancing payments
Balancing payments are due with the VAT return and must clear HMRC’s bank account by the last working day of the month if standard period end dates are used.
Late payments
If a business does not make POA or the balancing payment in full and on time HMRC will:
- take immediate action to recover the debt
- charge late payment interest
- consider charging late payment penalties on amounts unpaid after the balancing payment due date
- consider transferring a business from quarterly to monthly returns
Removal from a POA arrangement
If a business’s VAT liability falls below £2.3 million in the reference year HMRC will remove it from the arrangement six months later.
Alternative to payments on account
If making POA and submitting quarterly VAT returns does not suit a business, it can choose to make VAT returns and payments monthly.
Commentary
As may be seen, it is important to recognise the POA limit and to make payments on time. There is an obvious cash flow impact and plans should be put in place if the VAT turnover is nearing the threshold.
VAT: What is a proforma invoice and how can it be used?
VAT basics
Proforma invoices (proformas) are preliminary documents usually sent to buyers in advance of a delivery of goods/provision of services. Proformas will typically describe details of the purchase of goods/services and other important information, such as the terms of the transaction. Proformas are not “official” documents and represent an informal agreement. Usually, requesting a proforma represents a more serious interest on the part of a buyer than a quote – a buyer is generally committed to making a purchase but want to understand the details before proceeding with the approval process and making a binding agreement with the seller. They are therefore a useful business tool and use of them may result in a beneficial cashflow position for VAT (please see below).
Proforma translates from Latin as “for the sake of form”, and this provides an indication that the document is provisional or a step in a process.
It is also worth noting that the use of proformas is not mandatory.
The difference between an invoice and a proforma
Invoices (also called commercial invoices, VAT invoices or tax invoices) are distinct from proformas. They may contain similar information but serve different purposes. It is important to avoid confusing the two, since only invoices are legal documents; that is, they evidence a transaction and is the document on which VAT may be claimed. An invoice must contain certain information and there are specific legal obligations for providing them.
It is a matter of law whether an invoice is valid and when they must be issued. A proforma is not required to follow any set form, apart from the facts that they must not have an invoice number and must state that it is a proforma invoice. We also recommend that a proforma does not show the supplier’s VAT number for the avoidance of doubt.
Contents of a proforma
Proformas can be considered as “dummy invoices” and they are prepared by the seller usually to provide details of:
- the issuing business’s name, address, and contact details
- customer’s name and address
- date of issue
- length of time the pricing is valid
- the goods/services requested, including quantities, type, and physical specifications
- pricing, including individual costs as well as the total amount to be charged
- terms of sale, including eg; shipping and delivery dates
- payment terms
- whether VAT is applicable
However, there are no set formats for proformas.
Use for buyer
The purpose of a proforma is to provide the buyer with an accurate and complete good faith estimate they can use to decide whether or not to go ahead with a transaction. It also avoids surprises when the actual tax invoice is issued.
VAT implications
The main distinctions are that, compared to a tax invoice, a proforma:
- does not create a tax point
- the recipient is unable to recover input tax on a proforma
Very broadly, the tax point (time of supply) this is the earliest of; invoice date, receipt of payment, goods transferred or services completed. The tax point fact is helpful in tax planning for suppliers. Broadly, using proformas, requests for payment, or similar documents rather than issuing an invoice, defers a tax point and consequently when VAT is payable to HMRC. This is especially relevant to businesses which provide ongoing services (known as continuous supplies of services).
Please contact us if you require more information on the commercial use of proformas.
VAT: The Partial Exemption Annual Adjustment
An annual adjustment is a method used by a business to determine how much input tax it may reclaim.
Even though a partly exempt business must undertake a partial exemption calculation each quarter or month, once a year it will have to make an annual adjustment as well.
An annual adjustment is needed because each tax period can be affected by factors such as seasonal variations either in the value supplies made or in the amount of input tax incurred.
The adjustment has two purposes:
- to reconsider the use of goods and services over the longer period; and
- to re-evaluate exempt input tax under the de minimis rules.
An explanation of the Value Added Tax Partial Exemption rules is available here
Throughout the year
When a business makes exempt supplies it will be carrying out a partial exemption calculation at the end of each VAT period. Some periods it may be within the de minimis limits and, therefore, able to claim back all of its VAT and in others there may be some restriction in the amount of VAT that can be reclaimed. Once a year the business will also have to recalculate the figures to see if it has claimed back too much or too little VAT overall. This is known as the partial exemption annual adjustment. Legally, the quarterly/monthly partial exemption calculations are only provisional, and do not crystallise the final VAT liability. That is done via the annual adjustment.
The first stage in the process of recovering input tax is to directly attribute the costs associated with making taxable and exempt supplies as far as possible. The VAT associated with making taxable supplies can be recovered in the normal way while there is no automatic right of deduction for any VAT attributable to making exempt supplies.
The balance of the input tax cannot normally be directly attributed, and so will be the subject of the partial exemption calculation. This will include general overheads such as heating, lighting and telephone and also items such as building maintenance and refurbishments.
The calculation
Using the partial exemption standard method the calculation is based on the formula:
Total taxable supplies (excluding VAT) / Total taxable (excluding VAT) and exempt supplies x 100 = %
This gives the percentage of non-attributable input VAT that can be recovered. The figure calculated is always rounded up to the nearest whole percentage, so, for example, 49.1 becomes 50%. This percentage is then applied to the non-attributable input VAT to give the actual amount that can be recovered.
Once a year
Depending on a businesses’ VAT return quarters, its partial exemption year ends in either March, April, or May. The business has to recalculate the figures during the VAT period following the end of its partial exemption year and any adjustment goes on the return for that period. So, the adjustment will appear on the returns ending in either June, July, or August. If a business is newly registered for VAT its partial exemption “year” runs from when it is first registered to either March, April or May depending on its quarter ends.
Special methods
The majority of businesses use what is known as “the standard method”. However, use of the standard method is not mandatory and a business can use a “special method” that suits a business’ activities better. Any special method has to be “fair and reasonable” and it has to be agreed with HMRC in advance. When using a special method no rounding of the percentage is permitted and it has to be applied to two decimal places.
Commonly used special methods include those based on staff numbers, floor space, purchases or transaction counts, or a combination of these or other methods.
However, even if a business uses a special method it will still have to undertake an annual adjustment calculation once a year using its agreed special method.
De minimis limits
If a business incurs exempt input tax within certain limits it can be treated as fully taxable and all of its VAT can be recovered. If it exceeds these limits none of its exempt input tax can be recovered. The limits are:
- £625 per month on average (£1,875 per quarter or £7,500 per annum) and;
- 50% of the total input VAT (the VAT on purchases relating to taxable supplies should always be greater than the VAT on exempt supplies to pass this test)
The partial exemption annual adjustments are not errors and so do not have to be disclosed under the voluntary disclosure procedure. They are just another entry for the VAT return to be made in the appropriate VAT period.
Conclusion
If a business fails to carry out its partial exemption annual adjustment it may be losing out on some input VAT that it could have claimed. Conversely, it may also show that it has over-claimed input tax. When an HMRC inspector comes to visit he will check that a business has completed the annual adjustment. If it hasn’t, and this has resulted in an over-claim of input VAT, (s)he will assess for the error, charge interest, and if appropriate, raise a penalty. It is fair to say that partly exempt businesses tend to receive more inspections than fully taxable businesses.
VAT: Changes to the DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme
The DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme is a tax refund mechanism for people who build, or arrange to have built, a house they intend to live in. It also applies to converting commercial property into a house(s). This puts a person who constructs their own home on equal footing with commercial housebuilders. There is no need to be VAT registered in order to make the claim.
The Scheme can be complex, but here is our Top Ten Tips for claimants.
The Changes
From 5 December 2023, the follow changes apply:
- claimants will be allowed to submit claims electronically
- the deadline for making claims will be extended to six months (from three)
- the list of documents required to support a claim has been amended
- a new requirement for additional evidence when a derelict building has been converted into dwelling(s) – to be made on a specific form
These changes are set out in The Value Added Tax (Refunds to “Do-It-Yourself” Builders) (Amendment of Method and Time for Making Claims) Regulations 2023 and guidance is provided by HMRC here.
The new deadline applies to claims made on, or after 5 December 2023. The deadline, broadly, begins when a dwelling is complete. There is sometimes a dispute on the completion date, so this case and commentary may be of assistance.
VAT: Best judgement; what is it, and why is it important?
If HMRC carry out an inspection and decide that VAT has been underdeclared (eg: either by understating sales, applying the incorrect VAT rate, or overclaiming input tax) an inspector has the power to issue an assessment to recover VAT that it is considered underdeclared. This is set out in The VAT Act 73(1)
“Where a person has failed to make any returns … or where it appears to the Commissioners that such returns are incomplete or incorrect, they may assess the amount of VAT from him to the best of their judgment and notify it to him”.
So, the law requires that when an inspector makes an assessment (s)he must ensure that the assessment is made to the best of their judgement, otherwise it is invalid and will not stand.
Guidance to surviving a VAT inspection here.
HMRC’s methods of assessing cash businesses here.
Definition of best judgment
Per Van Boeckel vs HMCE (1981) the judge set out three tests:
- HMRC must make a value judgment on the material set before it honestly and bona fide and not knowingly set an inflated figure and then expect the taxpayer to disprove it on appeal
- there must be material available
- HMRC is not expected to do the work of the taxpayer but instead fairly interpret the material before it and come to a reasonable conclusion rather than an arbitrary one
If any of these three tests are failed, then best judgement has not been employed. However, the onus is on the appellant to disprove the assessment.
There were further comments on the matter:
“There are…obligations placed on the Commissioners to properly come to a view on the amount of tax that was due to the best of their judgement. In particular:
- a value judgement must be made on the material put before them
- they must perform their function honestly
- there must be material on which to base their judgement
- but they should not be required to do the job of the taxpayer, or carry out extensive investigations
This means that the assessing inspector must fairly consider all material placed before them and, on that material, come to a decision that is reasonable and not arbitrary, taking into account the circumstances of the business. In some cases, some “guesswork” may be required, but it should be honestly made based on the information available and should not be spurious, but HMRC must be permitted a margin of discretion.
Experience insists that it is usually more successful if the quantum of a best judgement assessment is challenged.
Where a business successfully disputes the amount of an assessment and the assessment is reduced, it will rarely fail the best judgement test.
In the case of MH Rahman (Khayam Restaurant) CO 2329/97 the High Court recognised the practice whereby the tribunal adopts a two-step approach, looking initially at the question of best judgement and then at the amount of the assessment. The message of the High Court appeared to be that the Tribunal should concern itself more with the amount of an assessment rather than best judgement.
Arguments which may be employed to reduce a best judgement assessment are, inter alia:
- period of calculation is unrepresentative
- wastage
- discounts
- staff use
- theft
- seasonal trends
- competition
- sales
- opening hours
- client base, etc
HMRC’s guidance to its own officers states that: Any assessments made must satisfy the best judgement criteria. This means that given a set of conditions or circumstances, “you must take any necessary action and produce a result that is deemed to be reasonable and not arbitrary”.
In other words, best judgement is not the equivalent of the best result or the most favourable conclusion. It is a reasonable process by which an assessment is successfully reached.
In the case of CA McCourtie LON/92/191 the Tribunal considered the principles set out in Van Boeckel and put forward three further propositions:
- the facts should be objectively gathered and intelligently interpreted
- the calculations should be arithmetically sound, and
- any sampling technique should be representative
Tribunals will not treat an assessment as invalid merely because they disagree as to how the judgement should have been exercised. It is possible that a Tribunal may substitute its own judgement for HMRC’s in respect of the amount of the assessment. However, this does not necessarily mean that because a different quantum for the assessment was arrived at that the assessment failed the best judgement test.
Further, it is not the function of the Tribunal to engage in a process that looks afresh at the totality of the evidential material before it (M & A Georgiou t/a Mario’s Chippery, QB October 1995 [1995] STC 1101).
It should be also noted that even if one aspect of an assessment is found not to be made to best judgement this should not automatically invalidate the whole assessment – Pegasus Birds [2004] EWCA Civ1015.
Summary
There are significant difficulties in arguing that an inspector did not use best judgement and it is a high bar to get over.
In order to succeed on appeal, it would be required to be demonstrated, to the judge’s satisfaction, that the assessment was raised:
- dishonestly
- vindictively
- capriciously
- arbitrarily
- spuriously
- via an estimate or a guess in which all elements or best judgement are absent
- wholly unreasonably
and that this action applies to the assessment in its entirety.
VAT reliefs for charities – A brief guide
Unfortunately, there is no “general” rule that charities are relieved of the burden of VAT.
In fact, charities have to contend with VAT in much the same way as any business. However, because of the nature of a charity’s activities, VAT is not usually neutral and often becomes an additional cost. VAT for charities often creates complex and time consuming technical issues which a “normal” business does not have to consider.
There are only a relatively limited number of zero rated reliefs specifically for charities and not for profit bodies, so it is important that these are taken advantage of. These are broadly:
- advertising services* received by charities
- purchase of qualifying goods for medical research, treatment or diagnosis
- new buildings constructed for residential or non-business charitable activities
- self-contained annexes constructed for non-business charitable activities
- building work to provide disabled access in certain circumstances
- building work to provide washrooms and lavatories for disabled persons
- supplies of certain equipment designed to provide relief for disabled or chronically sick persons
* HMRC have set out its views on digital/online advertising in Revenue and Customs Brief 13 (2020): VAT charity digital advertising relief.
There are also special exemptions applicable to supplies made by charities:
- income from fundraising events
- admissions to certain cultural events and premises
- relief from “Options to Tax” on the lease and acquisition of buildings put to non-business use
- membership subscriptions to certain public interest bodies and philanthropic associations
- sports facilities provided by non-profit making bodies
Although treating certain income as exempt from VAT may seem attractive to a charity, it nearly always creates an additional cost as a result of the amount of input tax which may be claimed being restricted. Partial exemption is a complex area of the tax, as are calculations on business/non-business activities which fundamentally affect a charity’s VAT position.
The reduced VAT rate (5%) is also available for charities in certain circumstances:
- gas and electricity in premises used for residential or non-business use by a charity
- renovation work on dwellings that have been unoccupied for over two years
- conversion work on dwellings to create new dwellings or change the number of dwellings in a building
- installation of mobility aids for persons aged over 60
Additionally, there are certain Extra Statutory Concessions (*ESCs) which benefit charities. These zero rate supplies made to charities, these are:
- certain printed stationery used for appeals
- collection boxes and receptacles
- lapel stickers and similar tokens, eg; remembrance day poppies
* ESCs are formal, published concessions but have no legal force.
We strongly advise that any charity seeks assistance on dealing with VAT to ensure that no more tax than necessary is paid and that penalties are avoided. Charities have an important role in the world, and it is unfair that VAT should represent such a burden and cost to them.
VAT: Partial exemption – updated HMRC guidance
HMRC has published updated partial exemption guidance in Manual PE21500.
The main changes are in respect of updated case law, including the Royal Opera House Court of Appeal case dealing with the attribution of input tax.
In that case the CoA considered: the test of direct and immediate link, economic necessity, business/non-business, and chains of transactions.